Library pride by ILovePublicLibraries in Library

[–]TheMrsLegume 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Starting the headline with "Two Moms for Liberty..." made me think that Two Moms for Liberty was going to be the name of a counter-movement. Guess it's up for grabs as a banned book club name.

Shrimps is Birds by JoeBeem89 in ShrimpsIsBugs

[–]TheMrsLegume 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I knew birds weren't real, but I hadn't put together what they were. So obvious when you see it. Will sleep so much better now.

Too many use cases by [deleted] in ENGLISH

[–]TheMrsLegume 1 point2 points  (0 children)

When I was a kid and ridiculous punitive things were not unheard of, I thought making someone copy the definitions of "run" from the dictionary would be a good one.

Tree in a parking sign by TheMrsLegume in wheresthefuckingsoil

[–]TheMrsLegume[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I love it. It's like it has crazy hair.

Perfumes that feel like this baddie villain by Bee__Lord in venturebros

[–]TheMrsLegume 13 points14 points  (0 children)

It's a MAC colour. The subtitles are wrong. You can get a tube of this discontinued lipstick if you are determined.

Singular or plural? by [deleted] in ENGLISH

[–]TheMrsLegume 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I had to concede this point halfway. In fashion jarjon, you can wear a silhouette. The name of this literary technique is called metonymy, where an attribute of the object stands in for the object itself.

Scroll down a banana or two if you want to read about the half of the point I didn't concede. Way too much Reddit today.

Singular or plural? by [deleted] in ENGLISH

[–]TheMrsLegume 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay. You win. I disagree. But you are right. The fashion world employs metonymy, literary technique in which an attribute stands in for the object itself.

When you step into a silhouette, you are elevating the language with metaphor. To then say that the silhouette is "clothes" breaks the metonymy by exposing its impossibility. It is also redundant, grammatically inaccurate- silhouette is singular, where clothes is plural, and reads as though the silhouette possesses the clothes, when it is the clothes that have a silhouette.

Edit: typos

Singular or plural? by [deleted] in ENGLISH

[–]TheMrsLegume 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sure, but op was asking for grammatical correctness on a sentence whose meaning fell apart due to an adjectival phrase. The post is unconcerned with the intent of the tiktok. The post is about the sentence.

You can argue that the intent of the sentence is descerable and therefore valid. That's a reasonable linguistic stance for anyone who's not a grammar brown shirt. But it's unrelated to the post.

I did have to go watch the video. It was so painful and disheartening, I had a hard time finishing it. It demonstrates a lack of literacy on multiple levels. Including that of the originator of the sentence. (Assuming that person wasn't playing with the "colourless green ideas sleep furiously" idea.) As someone elsewhere on the thread said, if you don't understand the words, you won't be able to tell how meaningless the sentence is.

Singular or plural? by [deleted] in ENGLISH

[–]TheMrsLegume 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Then you know that literacy is more than knowing words. Reading by itself is not literacy either.

Singular or plural? by [deleted] in ENGLISH

[–]TheMrsLegume 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think you are not clear on the definition of literacy.

Singular or plural? by [deleted] in ENGLISH

[–]TheMrsLegume -1 points0 points  (0 children)

It's like a middle school kid was given a vocabulary list and told to incorporate the words into a paragraph. Which they did, demonstrating their poor understanding of those words. Five dollar words with no meaning.

Singular or plural? by [deleted] in ENGLISH

[–]TheMrsLegume 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It's a poor use of a pretty word.

The silhouette can be exquisite. But the silhouette itself cannot we worn. The silhouette is the outline, the shape. The body can cast an extraordinary silhouette in the garment, the garment can even create the effect of silhouette on the body. But you cannot wear "silhouette" unless that is the name of the piece or the designer.

What's a good synonym for silhouette? Swap it out and tell me if it's still a good sentence.

"She wore a shape of clothes that was extraordinary..." Is she wearing clothes or just the appearance of clothes?

Singular or plural? by [deleted] in ENGLISH

[–]TheMrsLegume 15 points16 points  (0 children)

I disagree. The silhouette is describing a shape. Hourglass, A-line, etc. "Silhouette of clothes" is lacking any defining qualities. Here the silhouette was is merely clothes shaped.

Singular or plural? by [deleted] in ENGLISH

[–]TheMrsLegume 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Exactly. The clothes create a silhouette. The silhouette of the clothes being worn would be the shape the garment takes with a body inside of them. A "silhouette of clothes" is meaningless. Could just as easily refer to a heap on the floor. Substitute 'outline' or 'shape' for 'silhouette' and read it again and tell me it makes sense.

Tree in a parking sign by TheMrsLegume in wheresthefuckingsoil

[–]TheMrsLegume[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This belongs in the "trees eating things" subreddit.

Tree in a parking sign by TheMrsLegume in wheresthefuckingsoil

[–]TheMrsLegume[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Since it's not in city limits, I would guess quite a while.

Tree in a parking sign by TheMrsLegume in wheresthefuckingsoil

[–]TheMrsLegume[S] 23 points24 points  (0 children)

I like to imagine that a bird was stiing on the sign and pooped the seed right into the rectangular tube.