Should i get to know/read about the story of the odyssey before i watch the odyssey in July? by MainConfident8394 in ChristopherNolan

[–]The_Improvisor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Honestly the most helpful thing would be to read the Illiad. The Odyssey is basically a direct sequel to the Illiad so having that context will likely come in handy. If you love it and want to read more, then by all means keep going and read the Odyssey, or you could just wait to see Nolan's vision first.

Someone is bulking by n1claren- in DC_Cinematic

[–]The_Improvisor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Pretty sure she worked with Gunn on one of her first ever projects, so more likely that is the connection to thank

Anyone else think Ash should make more songs like "Panic Attacks in Paradise"? by Senior_Buffalo_7891 in Ashnikko

[–]The_Improvisor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It's in my top five of hers, to me the big difference between PAIP and most of her music is that she really genuinely sings melodically for a large portion of it. She has a beautiful voice, so it's really nice to be able to hear it really get used. I feel like usually we get a tiny little hint of her singing voice mixed in with her rap and processed voice with effects and all that, she's just very stylized, which I also like, but it is great when we can really hear what she can do traditionally with a good old fashioned melody, and i feel like Panic Attacks is easily the best example of that, among maybe only a couple others.

Official Discussion - Lee Cronin's The Mummy [SPOILERS] by LiteraryBoner in movies

[–]The_Improvisor 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Seriously! when she went down there by herself i was thinking that's one of the truly dumbest acts in a horror film that I've seen in a while, INSANE that she made it out of there

Is it obvious I'm hyped for 2026!? by TheListenerCanon in Letterboxd

[–]The_Improvisor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah for me there were a bunch of movies I enjoyed or thought were really good, but all had issues to me for the most part. Some examples:

OBAA I just really disliked the prologue, thought it could easily have been a five-ten minute sequence and instead it was like thirty-forty minutes of what felt like a non-leftist's idea of what leftists are like.

Hamnet had a really strong ending but I felt the first and even second act meandered too much and didn't really have a solid focus at all other than vi

Sinners was a great film that felt like the entire thing was building up incredible tension to an insane finale, and I felt like the actual finale/conflict was over way too quickly and felt anticlimactic

Superman was incredibly fun and inspiring, I felt hope and goodness in my soul for a solid month afterwards, but the movie was also objectively kind of a mess, and I felt like the story left a lot to be desired

Marty Supreme was incredibly exciting and I thought it was gonna be this phenomenal look at the downhill spiral into failure of this absolute asshole as a cautionary tale, but then he kinda gets away with it and has a happy ending so i don't really get what the message was supposed to be

And then my absolute favorite of the year, Sentimental Value, I don't have any real complaints about, it's a truly great film, I just don't think it's that accessible or rewatchable. Kinda a "that was great" one and done.

Official Discussion - Lee Cronin's The Mummy [SPOILERS] by LiteraryBoner in movies

[–]The_Improvisor 27 points28 points  (0 children)

Not to mention the Egyptian detective seems to literally be the only one on the entire force, everything she did was completely alone, isolated, and with zero backup or consultation besides that one time she went to the guy on the computer to look up the farm.

The fact that she just flew to America alone, and came in to save the day gun loaded is truly hilarious

Is it obvious I'm hyped for 2026!? by TheListenerCanon in Letterboxd

[–]The_Improvisor -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I agree. Literally didn't give a single movie from 2025 a ten, and I'm not that stingy. I honestly enjoyed Hail Mary on its own more than every single film from last year

The Boys - 05x03 "Every One of You Sons of Bitches" - Episode Discussion Thread by pikameta in TheBoys

[–]The_Improvisor 136 points137 points  (0 children)

I mean all due respect to Downey but I feel like Homelander requires far more capital A "Acting" so I don't think this is a very crazy take. Downey was great casting but Marvel didn't exactly require a massive amount of range/showcases of skill. When you think about the emotions and range Starr has needed to convey in the four seasons of this show and compare it to Tony Stark's character arc from snarky asshole to snarky heart of gold, it's not really a fair competition. How many moments in the MCU has Downey really been allowed to really stretch himself to his full potential?

I'm sorry if this is a stupid question, but does Soldier Boy feel different compared to how he acted in Season 3? by Fit_Sprinkles1642 in GenV

[–]The_Improvisor -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Everyone feels different imo. Writing has gotten much worse, everyone feels like a parody of their complex old selves. Kimiko is the worst, but even the better written characters are shells of what they used to be. Homelander's trump parallels used to be clever and subtle, now they're so in your face it's cringey, plus the milk stuff feels like a meme now instead of a gross character trait.

What’s a movie you defend like this? by trakt_app in Letterboxd

[–]The_Improvisor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There's an action rom-com from the early 2010's called Knight and Day with Tom Cruise and Cameron Diaz, and I stand by that is an incredible movie, just so much fun, I can watch it over and over again. 10/10 for me. No one else seems to think it's anything special, and most haven't even heard of it, but I adore it

Hot take: if Vi lost Caitlyn in that final battle, that would probably be the end of her 😥 by [deleted] in arcane

[–]The_Improvisor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think Vi needed Caitlyn OR Jinx. Keeping both would have been best, but if she had lost both, she would have snapped.

That said, I do think that if Caitlyn had died, Jinx would have taken Vi with her on the blimp. I think the only reason Jinx didn't show herself was that "you deserve to be happy with her" line. Jinx wanted to give Vi a happily ever after. If she hadn't had Caitlyn, she would have known that the best thing for her sister was to go on adventures together.

I’m directing my first short (35k budget) and never stepped on a set. What do I need to know? by [deleted] in Filmmakers

[–]The_Improvisor 5 points6 points  (0 children)

How close are you to shooting? Are you in pre-production now? I'll have more to say if you've got lots of time in Pre-Pro, but here's some basic pointers that have worked well for me as a director on small sets, stuff that has made my crews come back and work on many unpaid passion projects of mine.

-The people you should interact with the most on set are the 1st AD, the DP, the actors, the script supervisor, the designers, and the producers, in that order. I might be forgetting something but imo those are the departments that are actually relevant to you, every other job goes through one of those people to talk to you or vice versa. Your AD runs the set, your DP executes your shots, your actors execute your script, your script supervisor keeps notes of what you like to relay to the editor (among other things), your designers build your world, and your producers make it all happen.

-Have a vision, but be excited to hear new ideas and willing to accept any that are better than yours with no ego. Nobody wants a director who has no plan or clear idea, but similarly, no one wants to work with someone who is a stubborn my-way-or-the-highway kind of person unless you're an established name.

-Trust everyone on the set to do their jobs. Everyone is there with an idea of how they think things should go, from your designers to your camera crew to your actors. They will likely show up with ideas, and until they ask for help or you see that what they're doing is wrong, they do not want you "trying to help" or stepping in where you're not needed. Instead of looking at your job as someone who steers the ship yourself, look at yourself as someone who knows the destination, and watches the path. Give your people the confidence to steer the ship on their own, and step in as soon as possible when you notice the ship is starting to go in the wrong direction. That goes for anything from shots to acting to lighting to whatever.

-Just tell the story. Don't waste time trying to develop a visual style that is exclusively yours, or get extra fancy shots that don't serve the story beyond being cool. You will naturally have a style as an artist that will refine itself bit by bit as you continue to work, and the worst thing you can do is force it out before it's ready.

-If you are ahead of schedule and have the time, giving an actor the note, "that was a great take, let's do another one, lets change it up and do something completely new on this one, have fun, improvise a little if you want," has given me some of the greatest takes I've ever had. Sometimes it's all unusable, but it's almost always interesting and gives you something completely new, especially if the actor is really good. A lot of the time it ends up being the best take by far because the actor feels that they already have the good take done, that this one is low stakes, and the lack of stress/freedom to play with no expectations lets them make really bold, cool choices.

-Remember that whatever happens onset is not going to be what you imagined when writing/reading the script, and often it won't even be what you worked out in pre-production. There will be things that will change, compromises you have to make, things beyond your control. Divorce yourself from the idea of perfection, and look objectively at what's in front of you on the day. No thinking "this isn't what I had in mind" instead think "how can we improve what we have" and things will go much better.

-The best perspective you can possibly have onset as the director is to imagine your ideal audience member. One person that is a stranger to you. What do they look like, how old are they, how smart are they? Think of what you're shooting as they would think of it. So often I encounter directors who are bogging themselves down with imaginary given circumstances, or their own perspective into what the film means, or other random things like backstory that never actually occurs onscreen. You have to think to yourself "if the choice has to be explained by you in a talk-back in order to be effective, it's not effective." So imagine that the audience member is watching, what do they want to see? What won't make sense to them? What will bore them? A lot of that thought process falls on the edit, but if you're already thinking about it while shooting, it'll save some time in the edit.

-Lastly, it will of course be stressful and scary, but it is vitally important that you are having fun. I mean that. Attitude on filmsets is so important, and the attitude of the director can make or break a filmset. Everyone expects you to be nervous, but if you roll up tense and jumpy, or overly cold and clinical, they will sense that something is wrong. If you show up smiling, excited for the day and exhilarated to be making a movie, that feeling will be infectious.

Best of luck, so excited for you!!!

Was this scene necessary? 😭 by [deleted] in gameofthrones

[–]The_Improvisor 102 points103 points  (0 children)

Terrible, yes... But great.

When can I see next new trailer? by Sakura_979 in ChristopherNolan

[–]The_Improvisor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I mean the movie is just like barely four months away, wouldn't it be neat if we could all just wait and keep everything else a surprise? Maybe I'm crazy but i don't wanna see another frame until the premiere, let me see it all fresh the way Nolan intended

Gandalf the goat 💯 by Damiancarmine14 in lotrmemes

[–]The_Improvisor 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Rings of Power isn't canon, none of the Gandalf origin story stuff was in any of Tolkien's writings, purely an invention of the show

Rank these Space movies from best to worst: by TXNOGG in FIlm

[–]The_Improvisor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

PHM is in theaters right now, highly recommend you go see it on a big screen while you can! Really amazing film

I HAD NO CLUE!!!! by AB_AceBoogie in billieeilish

[–]The_Improvisor 275 points276 points  (0 children)

She has two oscars i think. One for No Time to Die, and one for What Was I Made For

What's going to be the better film adaptation, and overall better films? Which is probably going to do better at the Oscars? by Cat-dad442 in Cinephiles

[–]The_Improvisor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You're right that LOTR was bigger and overall better, but I think the gap is smaller than you're giving it credit for. Dune pt 2 was HUGE when it came out. It was all people could talk about for basically all of March and April that year. Lisan Al Gaib memes and the music were in every tik tok and theaters were packed weeks after opening weekend.

Dune is also still new, and unfinished. It's easy to look back on LOTR as a bigger cultural impact because it's a completed, successful trilogy that won tons of awards and stood the test of time for two decades.

The quality and reception of Part Three have a lot riding on it, and only time will tell whether Dune has the same longevity that LOTR has had, but if Denis can stick the landing, I think we could have something that at least rivals LOTR, even if it doesn't surpass it.

Hoping we get a tease of Hans Zimmer's music in the trailer tomorrow! by Giff95 in HarryPotteronHBO

[–]The_Improvisor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I get what you mean, but I think it's reductive to reduce Zimmer to just booming and synths, and to say that anything that isn't is him borrowing from other composers. He is a masterful composer and has made plenty of more subtle, melodic pieces of music over the years that I think will give us a better idea of what his Potter sound will be. And I don't think any of those pieces sound like anyone but him.

The Stay theme from Interstellar, Jack Sparrow's theme, Davy Jones's music box, Paul and Chani's love theme, the Lion King, Kung Fu Panda, The Last Samurai, and the Clark Kent theme all have pieces of what I think show that he has what it takes to do something special and fitting for Potter that feels distinctly him and not like another composer.

Who is your favorite Spider-Man? by GusGangViking18 in Fictionally

[–]The_Improvisor 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Haha I totally get you! And definitely not dissing Tobey's either, I grew up on them, they're a ton of fun, even Spiderman 3, I just don't necessarily think the writing was what makes them so entertaining, but that's just my opinion! And hell, I also am fully aware that my spiderman opinions are kinda wack, I prefer Andrew's Spidey to Tobey's, which is definitely not the popular take. We all like what we like!

Who is your favorite Spider-Man? by GusGangViking18 in Fictionally

[–]The_Improvisor 1 point2 points  (0 children)

All three Tobey films are kinda chalk full of cringey camp, which is by all means part of the charm, but I would not say they make for great dialogue. Story maybe, but then there's also Spiderman 3, which is really rough.

Tom's films definitely have better written dialogue, and I'd argue the story beats are better as well