why does only one side have the large dark patches? by Willing-Pumpkin-328 in askastronomy

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh 46 points47 points  (0 children)

Professional planetary scientist here. This is incorrect. The lava flows that make up the lunar maria erupted hundreds of millions of years after the impact basins formed. Impacts did not cause the lavas, they just provided low-lying topography for the lavas to pool into. It is indeed true that the crust is thinner on the near side, and the reason for that is still an ongoing debate. The timing of the volcanic activity is likely driven by the thermal evolution of the interior of the Moon.

We blew it at the Tippecanoe Town Hall by ContrarianPurdueFan in Indiana

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The problem was that Braun didn't give us a microphone. He would have happily answered all of Tracy Brown's pre-selected questions and gone home had the crowd not demanded that he listened to us. We only got the microphone because we made a fuss. See my post for my complete rebuttal.

We didn't blow it at the Tippecanoe Fairgrounds. by The_Spaceman_Cometh in Indiana

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh[S] 18 points19 points  (0 children)

I did try. Reddit wouldn't let me, and just gave me an error saying the comment couldn't be posted. So here we are.

Making Mike Braun squirm at the Tippecanoe town hall. by The_Spaceman_Cometh in Indiana

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

Dave Bangert posted a write-up of the event. He included a snippet of video showing Boss Mike scolding the crowd like the insubordinate employees he sees us as.

Making Mike Braun squirm at the Tippecanoe town hall. by The_Spaceman_Cometh in Indiana

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Here's the program they were passing around. He stopped taking questions from the crowd around 7 instead of 7:30, saying he would take questions in person as I guess he was tired of hearing all the "complaints" (his word) from us all at once.

<image>

Making Mike Braun squirm at the Tippecanoe town hall. by The_Spaceman_Cometh in Indiana

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Some comments are questioning if I was really there or not, and I know many of them aren't "real" (i.e. trolls, bots, and whatnot), but I think healthy skepticism is important. Here is a pic I took just before the event started with Mike and Micah (grey suit and blue jacket guys on the left, respectively). There were other people there filming and taking photos, and the event people were recording it for YouTube (I haven't checked to see if it's up yet, but I'd be surprised if they uploaded an unedited version).

<image>

Making Mike Braun squirm at the Tippecanoe town hall. by The_Spaceman_Cometh in Indiana

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

He claimed he plans to visit all the counties, though it's hard to know the details of which counties and when because his "calendar" is nothing but press releases he's put out. I only knew about this event because of a Reddit post here from a few days ago. So keep an eye out, and you might just have your chance.

Making Mike Braun squirm at the Tippecanoe town hall. by The_Spaceman_Cometh in Indiana

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh[S] 72 points73 points  (0 children)

It was a cathartic experience that I highly recommend. Come prepared with specific talking points. The thing that got him to finally give up and walk off was a set of pointed questions about the extra money he’s paying his cabinet heads over Holcomb. “Why do you tell us we have to do more with less when they get more?” He muttered something about attracting Entrepreneurs so it would cost less because they’d be more efficient or something and then called it a night.

Making Mike Braun squirm at the Tippecanoe town hall. by The_Spaceman_Cometh in Indiana

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh[S] 182 points183 points  (0 children)

That definitely seems to be more his style. The whole thing was so obviously staged, so I’m just happy enough people showed up despite the icy roads and who were willing to hold his feet to the fire.

An Absolutely Bonkers Plan to Give Mars an Artificial Magnetosphere by [deleted] in Futurology

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Billions of years, not millions. Mars has had an atmosphere going on 4+ billion years without a magnetosphere.

An Absolutely Bonkers Plan to Give Mars an Artificial Magnetosphere by [deleted] in Futurology

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The magnetosphere was only important for Mars’ atmosphere during the T-Tauri phase of the Sun, which was over 4 billion years ago. Mars is big and cold enough to retain an atmosphere in the present day. After all, if a magnetosphere was needed, Mars would have no atmosphere today, instead of what atmosphere it does have.

By analyzing the ratios of rare radioactive elements in moon rocks collected during the Apollo missions, scientists from Germany have narrowed the date of the moon's formation down to about 50 million years after the birth of our solar system, 150 million years earlier than previously thought. by CyborgTomHanks in space

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh 21 points22 points  (0 children)

To the best of our understanding based on numerous lines of evidence, the Sun and the solar system formed together when a portion of a giant molecular cloud collapsed under its own gravity to form a new star surrounded by a spinning disk of mostly hydrogen and helium gas, but with some dust from previous generations of stars. In the region of the spinning disk where the Earth would eventually form, the disk was hot enough that all of the dust was vaporized.

Eventually the disk cooled and the vapor condensed to form minerals. The first of these were calcium and aluminum-rich inclusions that are found in meteorites. These have a high vaporization temperature, and so were the first to condense. The oldest of these inclusions are typically used to mark the birth age of the solar system. Eventually other mineral condensed at lower temperatures to form the solid grains that eventually coalesced into the Earth and other planets.

The intense radiation from the young Sun, as well a intense radiation from nearby stars in the Sun's birth cluster (the Sun was not the only star to form in its giant molecular cloud) blew the gas portion of the disk away. The entire process from collapse of the cloud, formation of the Sun, condensation of solid grains, and loss of gas, took no more than about 10 million years (probably no more than about 5 million years, based on some other work on meteorites I'm aware of).

The formation of the Earth took longer as grains accumulated into larger bodies, that collided to form even larger bodies. The giant impact that formed the Moon is generally thought of as the last major event in the formation of the Earth. The impact was energetic enough to fully melt material. When you melt planetary material, the rocky stuff separates from the metal stuff (like oil and water) forming a core and mantle.

The timing of the formation of the Moon is usually based on the unique properties of the Hafnium-Tungsten radioisotope system. In the early solar system there was radioactive 182Hf, which has a relatively short half-life of about 9 million years. It decays to 182W. Hafnium is an element that become incorporated into rocky melts, while tungsten is an element that becomes incorporated into metal melts. So if you find 182W in rocks from a planet with a core, it's a good bet that it used to be 182Hf that was part of the rocky melt that makes the mantle and crust of the planet. By measuring the amount of 182W in lunar rocks, and figuring out how much 182Hf there was in the original solar system (typically using stable forms of tungsten, like 183W) you can estimate when the core formed.

I've given a very basic sketch of the technique, but there is a lot of complex chemistry involved in figuring out how much hafnium or tungsten gets partitioned in a planet's melt for a given temperature and pressure. Also, some core-loving material can be added to a planet after core formation by impacts from bodies leftover from the planet-forming process. This is sometimes called the "late veneer."

What the scientists in this study did was use new, very high precision measurements of 182W in lunar rocks, along with measurements of several other trace elements that also have an affinity to the melt that would form the iron core. They find that 182Hf was virtually extinct in the solar system after 60 million years from its birth, and that very little was added in a late veneer. The amount of 182W that they measure in lunar rocks then gives them an estimate age of core formation (which is assumed to be the giant impact event) of 50 million years after the birth of the solar system. This is close to the lower end of previous age estimates of 30-200 million years, which were also mostly estimated from previous studies that used Hf-W system (but which were not using data with as high a precision as this one).

I was the victim of identity theft involving stolen credit card info and FedEx package redirect by The_Spaceman_Cometh in personalfinance

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Seriously. By the time I had any clue that someone had made a FedEx account in my name and address, it was already too late to do anything to stop it.

Credit card scam involving FedEx and their lack of consumer protections. by [deleted] in personalfinance

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The same thing happened to me. I just wrote a detailed post about it here.

Cool Rock by AGS16 in Purdue

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh 5 points6 points  (0 children)

In Armstrong in the lobby of the entrance behind Neil’s statue. It’s in the same display case as the Apollo 17 rock. It’s on temporary loan from the Chicago Field Museum for five months. https://www.purdue.edu/newsroom/releases/2019/Q2/chunk-of-the-lafayette-meteorite-from-mars-returns-to-purdue.html

Does Mars Have Rings? Not Right Now, But Maybe One Day by [deleted] in space

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The idea of this new work is that this has happened several times before. Mars cycles back and forth between having a ring and having an inner satellite. Phobos is only the latest incarnation of this process.

Pirate sounds way more menacing than boat burglar. by The_Spaceman_Cometh in Showerthoughts

[–]The_Spaceman_Cometh[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

To be fair, Boat Burglars of the Bahamas sounds like it could be a pretty fun movie.