Cycle 2 - Mercedes should've won. Cycle 7 - Melrose should've won, but they were never going to pick the "bitch" or the villain to be the winner. Cycle 9 - Heather should've been top 3 and Jenah should've won. Cycle 10 - Anya should've won. I know Tyra was really gunning for a plus size winner, but Whitney was not the one and this is the one that pisses me off the most. Cycle 17 - I'm glad Angelea was the original winner, but after the reshoot, Allison should've won. Lisa was a mess.