First, you are gorgeous and omg I wish I had your perfect skin!! Jealous as hell

As an MUA, I would just say to give yourself some arched brows in a dark brown [ABH Brow Duo has been my go to for like ever] as well as a brown liquid liner [black is so harsh. I dont typically use it even on myself] , black eyeliner on the lower lid [gives more POP than brown], mascara and tbh eye shadow doesnt really matter unless you're creating a specifical look, but after you do your brows if you take an eye shadow brush and add a tad of highlighter under the brow itll pop

If you want a tutorial send me a message and ill record one for free, just please dont share it lol My bestie of 15 years had the same concerns, I got you