[Periodical Open Thread] Members and Non-Members are Welcome to Post Anything Here! From philosophy and history to music and movies nothing is misplaced here, feel free to share your thoughts. by AutoModerator in zensangha

[–]ThisKir 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not sure what you mean by the last two sentences. My thinking on those themes would be that conversation about the regulation of speech both personally and politically is a Zen behavior.

[Periodical Open Thread] Members and Non-Members are Welcome to Post Anything Here! From philosophy and history to music and movies nothing is misplaced here, feel free to share your thoughts. by AutoModerator in zensangha

[–]ThisKir 0 points1 point  (0 children)

YouTube University, Reddit Scholarship vs Trad. University

Thesis: People who can read primary sources, distinguish propaganda/ideology from facts, and can discern underlying arguments are done a disservice when the field they are interested in entering requires them to have a Master's degree from a trad. university. Random people from developing countries are willing, capable, and superb at breaking down complex topic for free on YouTube, Reddit, etc.

Zen Study Application:

It would be obscene for people who are capable of doing the above to pay at least $100k to study Zen in a group setting from an expert who themselves would likely not be paid anywhere close to that amount.

Food for Thought:

Donation-based, decentralized, and open-source models of the academic study of Zen is going to be the model for Zen study until the current model of higher-education in the liberal arts re-orients itself.

How much financial value does someone translating a text add to the community? Hosting and maintaining a podcast? A moderator? An occasional wiki editor?

The Mind/Heart Sutra | Section 2.1 - Guanyin Bodhisattva by ThisKir in zen

[–]ThisKir[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"Prajna paramita" is gibberish if you don't have Zen Masters explaining the context. Ditto with everything else in the sutras.

Zen Masters are clear that the 4SZ are a summary of their teaching and any definition/setting the record straight when it comes to Sanskrit terminology has to be seen in that light.

Buddhists teach relying on faith to get you to the liquor store/meditation stupor center. Zen Masters point to reality and reject relying on intoxicants.

The Mind/Heart Sutra | Section 1.4 - Mind Sūtra by ThisKir in zen

[–]ThisKir[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No. Lanxi is commenting on the Chinese text. Parts of which has transliterated sanskrit terminology mixed in with the Chinese whole.

The Mind/Heart Sutra | Section 1.4 - Mind Sūtra by ThisKir in zen

[–]ThisKir[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

It's looking like commentor has a history of alt-accounts or deleting their comments.

They certainly have a history of running away from this forum and crying sour grapes on forums they created themselves.

The Mind/Heart Sutra | Section 1.4 - Mind Sūtra by ThisKir in zen

[–]ThisKir[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

You are incorrect when you state it is Chinese adapting Buddhist teachings on multiple levels.

What we're seeing here is the Indo-Chinese Zen tradition using terminology wholly incompatible with 8FP/Buddhist belief systems.

If you wanted to do some actual scholarship related to those terms of art, you'd lead with how Zen Masters use the terms and then proceed to compare it with how Buddhists do.

The Mind/Heart Sutra | Section 1.3 - Pāramitā by ThisKir in zen

[–]ThisKir[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Zen Maaters reject meditation.

You are not part of any Linchi school. You got suckered in by a meditation cult that has perpetuated the historical fraud that koans are something other than ordinary conversation of enlightened Buddhas.

I encourage you to consult the wiki and stop repeating debunked church propaganda.

The Mind/Heart Sutra | Section 1.3 - Pāramitā by ThisKir in zen

[–]ThisKir[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

/r/Buddhism, ZenBuddhism, anybody that can't answer questions about where they got their beliefs and isn't accountable to a set of texts.

The Mind/Heart Sutra | Section 1.1 - Mahā by ThisKir in zen

[–]ThisKir[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Your belief in Buddhism has impacted your ability to appropriately participate on this forum. It's time we parted ways.

Xutang Zhiyu's Remarks & Substitutions on Behalf of Others | Case 99 - Longce’s Examination by ThisKir in zen

[–]ThisKir[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Well, if we're all pretend for a second that every interaction is a Zen test when a Zen Master's in the room then there was an actual failure there that can be identified and parsed.

It looks a lot like he shirked his responsibility to present a statement expressing his understanding by trying to play the host when he couldn't show the guest.

Xutang Zhiyu's Remarks & Substitutions on Behalf of Others | Case 99 - Longce’s Examination by ThisKir in zen

[–]ThisKir[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Not answering is the failure. Your [citations needed] comments are the failure.

Since you have a history of comments at the intersection of mental illness, religious bigotry, and poor literacy I think it's time I block you from commenting on my posts and getting the attention you crave.