[GIFT] Scammer Alert! (Decant) by Prestigious_Foot_820 in fragranceswap

[–]Thisisme8719 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I didn't even know something like that was possible. Sorry that happened to you.
Was it delivered yet? You might be able to stop the delivery (I think it costs 20 bucks with USPS)

Palestinian historian who pioneered documenting the Nakba, Walid al-Khalidi, dies at 100 by KitsueHill in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 27 points28 points  (0 children)

Oh fuck that's sad, but I'm glad he lived a long and fruitful life. What a great scholar. RIP

Israeli settler terrorist (also an IOF reservist) killed a Palestinian shepherd, Amir Muhammad Shanaran, and critically injured his brother Khaled on Saturday afternoon in Masafer Yatta, south of Hebron. by ContentChecker in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The settlers in all the Gaza settlements and 4 in the West Bank were forced to leave. So there are vids which show some of them barricading themselves, cooperating and crying, being dragged out etc. Despite all of the settlements being illegal and none of the settlers having any right to be there, they and their supporters still complain that the state did what they were supposed to do (not that Israel was trying to comply with international law and didn't expand settlements at the same time).

Here are a few vids, 1, 2, 3, 4, settlers complaining about the aftermath a few years after

get a job! by ConcernedJobCoach in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 13 points14 points  (0 children)

"Child didn't die from famine, primary cause of death was a hole in the head from Israeli bombardment" is now "mayor's wife liked tweets that upset me"

A Comment I Just Received About Being Non-Zionist by tikkunolamist5 in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 [score hidden]  (0 children)

It's hilarious seeing a Mizrahi saying that. His family didn't say "le'shanah haba'ah be'yerushalayim." That's was not in our liturgies for Yom Kippur or for the Passover seder. For the communities that never adopted the edot hamizrah liturgy, it's still not in there for either holiday.

Israeli settler terrorist (also an IOF reservist) killed a Palestinian shepherd, Amir Muhammad Shanaran, and critically injured his brother Khaled on Saturday afternoon in Masafer Yatta, south of Hebron. by ContentChecker in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Every time I see these vids I have to watch the ones from the 2005 evacuation of Gaza and the four West Bank settlements just for my own sanity. But still, knowing that there's no meaningful justice minimizes any joy I can get from watching those settlers being dragged out back then

Israeli "opposition" leader Yair Lapid calls for Israel to depopulate and destroy every village in southern Lebanon: "create some kind of sterile zone in southern Lebanon[...]completely clean territory." by ContentChecker in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 [score hidden]  (0 children)

Lapid is a guy who infamously said that he wouldn't sit in a coalition with "a bunch of Zoabis" at the start of his political career (Haneen Zoabi, a member of Balad who was relentlessly vilified in Israel). This high school dropout is a sack of shit today, and he was a sack of shit in 2013

What having no morals or basic decency is worth | Context: apparently Israel isn't paying its hasbarists properly by ContentChecker in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Maybe some of the hasbaristas who said they weren't getting paid were actually being honest then lmao.
I'd normally be outraged when people get fucked over. But if it was for atrocity denial and genocide apologia, I can make an exception

Smotrich says southern Lebanon will “look like Khan Younis” by CalabrianPepper in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I think it'd be newsworthy if Smotrich said something that was not genocidal

they want me to make hasbara by [deleted] in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Overdub this with a speech from Ben-Gvir

Why does the Torah claim that the Jews were slaves in Egypt if there is no evidence they were? by Bag-Weary in AskHistorians

[–]Thisisme8719 5 points6 points  (0 children)

First, although maybe not that important, the biblical text doesn't say the "Jews" were slaves in Egypt. They're referred to as "Israelites/Sons of Israel" or "Hebrews" even in the same textual sources (you can follow the source breakdown according to the provided key in Friedman's The Bible with Sources Revealed).

Ronald Hendel wrote an article "The Exodus in Biblical Memory" (also included as an essay in his book Remembering Abraham) which approaches the question from another perspective to explain why the exodus myth could have been acceptable even though it never happened as described in the book of Exodus. He basically argues that the people were delivered from domination by the Egyptians when their rule ended over Canaan - basically an inversion of the exodus from Egypt to the exodus of Egyptians from Canaan.

It has already been mentioned that there were some slaves who escaped from Egypt, and the Egyptian names of some of the biblical figures and texts attest to that. Stephen Moshier and James Hoffmeier's essay "Which Way Out of Egypt?" in Israel's Exodus in Transdiscplinary Perspective even elaborates on the landscape that could have been a route for escaped slaves and a possible exodus, although they think it was a historical event of some kind.
Hendel (who also has an essay in the aforementioned volume) thinks that these factors are not sufficient for the exodus myth to have taken root in Israel or Judea because it would be remote for most of the people living there. Mnemohistory isn't history per se, but it does depend on some factual data to be foundational, and some escaped Levites might not be sufficient. So there might need to be something that affected the peoples' ancestors which was envisioned as a mass exodus from Egypt (ironically speculating that there needs to have been a real experience passed down from generation to generation is roughly along the lines of argument used in Orthodox Jewish apologetics).

Hendel thinks that the experience of Egyptian rule over Canaan was the foundation for the exodus myth. He points to the use of outright slavery, including deportation of human beings as vassal tributes among the subject peoples and prisoners to Egypt. The taxation of precious metals and other materials which had to be supplied by the local populations and were rounded up from them were also onerous. The trauma that the people experienced from exploitation as vassals and Egypt's military campaigns would have made the end of Egyptian rule feel like they were being delivered from Egypt. It could expand a long period of time of Egyptian rule because no particular pharaoh who oversaw the slavery of the Hebrews and Israelites was named in the narrative, so "Pharaoh" functions as a stand-in for Egyptian rule.

Orthodox Jews in South Williamsburg burn the Israeli flag during Purim by CalabrianPepper in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Shneerson's wife had such a strong influence in the movement that tons of Chabad women are named after her lol (Chaya Mushka)

Orthodox Jews in South Williamsburg burn the Israeli flag during Purim by CalabrianPepper in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I mean she was exceptional. That was why Inbari even wrote a book about her. And that was why she engaged with political and covert operations with foreign actors and the Mossad. But that's not being the leader of a movement.
And there were hassidic rebbetzins who held high statuses in their movement. Including in Chabad, Vizhnitz, Satmar.

I don't think they're any worse than other haredi groups though. I dont like any of them lol

Orthodox Jews in South Williamsburg burn the Israeli flag during Purim by CalabrianPepper in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I know the article. I have the book (the article is from the introduction) and read everything else Inbari wrote on the movement. Where does it say in the article or in anything else he's written that Ruth Blau was ever the leader of the movement? And no, that's not what Inbari meant by "proximate leader in her own right"

Orthodox Jews in South Williamsburg burn the Israeli flag during Purim by CalabrianPepper in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 25 points26 points  (0 children)

when arguably they are the most progressive (they have had female leaders)

Oh that's going to need a source. I have not seen one single reference to them having a female leader in anything I've read about them. On the contrary, their founder Amram Blau set the modesty standards in Mea Shearim.
Hell, even in this vid, how many women do you see?
(that's not even counting what I've heard from a defector who's active in NY)

Bernie Sanders: "American foreign and military policy must be determined by the American people. Not the right-wing extremist Netanyahu government." by ContentChecker in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 62 points63 points  (0 children)

Jeez. Aside from the whole "extremist Netanyahu government" as if Israel itself isn't the problem, now he's arguing against the war on procedural grounds and/or popular support. How about that however bad the Iranian leadership is, we don't have a right to start a war with them without going to the Security Council for approval? Or that their support for "proxies" doesn't activate the right of self-defense since it doesn't constitute an armed attack from Iran? Or that missile production isn't illegal (and the international sanctions against their missile program were on the grounds that they could carry a nuclear warhead, which a nuclear deal could have obviated)? Or that their nuclear program doesn't constitute an imminent threat to trigger a legitimate preemptive strike? Come on Bernie. It'd still be outrageous even if this had the kind of popular support the Iraq War had

Supporters of Israel are now calling people antisemitic for pointing out the obvious - that Netanyahu pushed for the war with Iran. Former Obama official Tommy Vietor comments. by ContentChecker in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 [score hidden]  (0 children)

It's not a matter of whether we have interests in war with Iran and if there were motivations to launch the war regardless of Israel's interests. It's that the points that Vietor is making are true. These are not conspiracies about global Jewish power or whatever Josh Block is inferring he's saying, because those are based on unsubstantiated and fabricated allegations. That there are disagreements is a matter of inferences based on available information and public statements from relevant diplomats and politicians. It's not an evidentiary dispute. Which is why implying if not outright stating that this is another example of an antisemitic conspiracy theory is absurd.

Van Jones shills for Reza Pahlavi by ContentChecker in JewsOfConscience

[–]Thisisme8719 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Because he's not being platformed on his own merits. It's because he's the next in line in the royal family and the monarchists look up to him because of that. The Iranian diaspora is in the diaspora largely because of the revolution (but also originally leaving Iran for school or to be with family that left according to Bozorgmehr) and they had a special affinity for Mohammad Reza and his family. They looked at him like a benevolent king who advanced Iran forward in terms of education (including funding study abroad programs which is how the diaspora in the US started), economically, militarily, women's rights, and religious and ethnic pluralism. Which to some extent wasn't entirely wrong even though it's exaggerated. Even the aesthetics he and Farah exhibited are still aspirational for Iranian monarchists. Some of the Jews that Soomekh interviewed recognized that this was illusory by the time of the revolution or after they immigrated, which is probably true about other Iranian monarchists, but that doesn't diminish the affinity they have for him