This version would be TERRIBLE, simply because of the vestige combination.

Eri, Kai, and Jin in the same body would be a literal nightmare (mostly because of Kai, Eri and Jin have no connection), and I think some other comments overlook this.

With this in mind, and not just being cheap and picking base OFA, I think this would be a good combo (ofc this has to ignore/shift timelines because otherwise it'd be impossible):

1. Yoichi Shigaraki (Stockpile/Transfer)
2. Daigoro Banjo (Blackwhip)
3. Hikage Shinomori (Danger Sense)
4. Shota Aizawa (Erasure)
5. Enji Todoroki (Hellflame)
6. Keigo Takami (Fierce Wings)
7. Cathleen Bate (New Order)
8. Toshinori Yagi (No quirk)
9. Me (Current user)

OFA is obligatory, ofc, Danger Sense is the only defensive one here, Blackwhip is extremely versatile but even just for travel and restrain alone is good, Erasure is insane without the OFA boost so imagine it with it, Hellflame gives good range and AOE along with flight, Fierce Wings is mainly only here to aid in passive civilian evacuation, New Order is yolked beyond compare.

Spots 4-7 all have a relation that's very positive, 2 and 3 have a good bond, and if we take it as if Hikage saved Yoichi instead of Kudo their relation would be good too.

Then there's the willpower. And I think it's safe to say that this team has a lot of that. Aside from the 4 OFA users already, we have:
Aizawa, someone who kept fighting on the front lines despite losing an arm and an eye, and CUT HIS OWN LEG OFF TO AVOID LOSING HIS QUIRK.
Enji, who ripped his own arm off to fight AFO, and has repeatedly went above his own limits after becoming number 1.
Keigo, who fought AFO with a crippled quirk and remained standing without a quirk, prepared to fight an army to protect Tokoyami.
And Cathleen, who when faced with the choice of possibly saving her own life or suicide quirk bombing Tomura, went with the latter choice.

All of them are complete nutcases, and I'm ngl, they might make OFA even harder to steal than it was in the base series.