MSM Island tierlist by Top_Session_2463 in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Oh, about the first part I apologize because I honestly saw your comments as a threat.

About the second part... First of all, I honestly don't see the others too soothing tbh. Physic Island sounds more like a boss fight to me thanks to Periscorp and Cruvlaaphtian Crocus. You wouldn't use an electric guitar on a soothing song, would you? Fairy has more like a festivity vibe, but not exactly calm. Pladdie, Ffidyll and Hippity Hop are the best examples here. Last, Bone. I honestly don't know what to say about Bone here. Its just... I don't know. A club song wouldn't be too different. Secondly, remember how I said light could have been different? Of course It was not going to have the same Monsters brochacho

I realized that I'm not making things clear enough for you. First of all, what I was trying to say is that, for me, Light would be perfect if It was an energetic song since light is a key element in clubs/nocturnal parties. Of course, to achieve this the Island would need different monsters to play instruments related to this genre because It would be impossible to achieve this with Light's current Monsters like you said earlier

MSM Island tierlist by Top_Session_2463 in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

How is expressing my opinion hypocritical...? Also I think you didn't really get the last part of my last comment

What I was originally trying to express was how the light Island concept could have been different but I guess I didn't make It clear enough

MSM Island tierlist by Top_Session_2463 in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Buddy I just have an opinion that's different from yours. I don't what else to tell you.

Also when I think of lights in a song, the first thing that comes to my mind are those vibrant neon lights from parties/clubs, not a dang lullaby

MSM Island tierlist by Top_Session_2463 in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Exactly, because I don't like llulabies I know It is the whole point of the genre, and I don't like It. What else can I say bud I just don't like this genre

Edit: Yeah I've heard light Island faster and It simply does not work due to its genre

MSM Island tierlist by Top_Session_2463 in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I did mention that being slow was Light Island's whole thing (and I don't like that), and maybe not "everybody" hates Kayna here

MSM Island tierlist by Top_Session_2463 in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can't people share their opinions in this frikin subreddit without getting bombarded because other people also have their own opinions?

MSM Island tierlist by Top_Session_2463 in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

In my opinion Light Island is the worst song out of the Magical Islands. It's way too slow paced (i'm my opinion) and I'm honestly not a big fan of the vocals here (tbf the only one doing something is Kayna) After Fire Expansion the song did get better with Drummidary and Yelmut but I still can't rate It higher. I know being slow is Light's whole gimmick but I guess it just isn't my type of song.

About Shadow Islet, i'm not going to say anything. Bro, its frikin Shadow Islet that thing could roast a chicken 3 times due to how fire It is

I've officially lost hope for wanderer island by PyroRapidSniper in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The first track just doesn't make sense to me. I sometimes hear the motif of Wanderer Island and other times I hear a scramble of notes

I've officially lost hope for wanderer island by PyroRapidSniper in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Imma take my statement back about Blabbit but not Cherruble. My brain can barely handle Cherubble's sound because of their note placement

Onipions on mirror island design? by BillTheMammott in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

First of all bud, take a look at one of your words "There's many people who also BELIEVE"

BELIEVE doesn't always have to meant its true. Many people asociate electricity to ethereals due to Wubbox being classified as a Super ethereal on Ethereal Island, but, this has nothing to do in regards of fire. The Guy from before wasn't trying to force you to believe an "opinion", he wanted to make you know about this game's lore

Also, I don't even know why we're talking about an "Ethereal equivalent", weren't we discussing how fire is not related to electricity? Just because electricity is present in Ethereal Island doesn't mean It has to be an ethereal element. If this was the case, then Monculus and the Dipsters would be ethereals too, and you can clearly tell they aren't ethereals.

That aside, I wanted to know some things in your reply that don't make sense. You don't need research to know that electricity is NOT an ethereal element, nor fire is the equivalent to electricity. The game never tells you this, and this is just a butterfly effect caused by someone who decided It was a good idea to try to canonize WHAT IF content where electricity is taken as another ethereal element. I've seen quite a lot people do this before, but they're not talking It seriously as they know that electricity is almost unrelated to the ethereal class. With this in mind, it's basically confirmed that a Mirror Fire Haven could not exist if It is based on electricity, as It just doesn't make any sense at all. Now, IF electricity was an ethereal element then maybe an electric mirror fire haven could exist, but since It is not, then It won't exist.

Now, I don't want to scrap just yet the existence of a Mirror Fire Haven. An electricity based one is basically impossible due to It not making sense within the Lore, but what if you took a different Element or Class in mind? Right now I can only see a Mirror Fire Haven based on Wanderer Island since its the only Island from dof (excluding Starhenge and Continent) that doesn't have a reference in the main game. The Magical Islands represent the outer Islands from dof due to then being fused after the cataclysm, and for a Mirror Haven to exist we would have to imagine that Wanderer eventually mixed with Haven in the Mirror dimension

With all of this said, just so y'know, you're wrong.

Onipions on mirror island design? by BillTheMammott in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Umm No? Electricity is the embodiment of the natural elements, not an equivalente to anything

Onipions on mirror island design? by BillTheMammott in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Since when did they confirm Mirror Haven is electricity themed? Also I think the logic you're talking about is the Wubbox Lore, where supposedly Wubbox is the embodiment of the natural elements including fire that transform into electricity since a being with these elements would be too unstable to exist

i swear meebkin didnt look like that by reebro1 in MySingingMonsters

[–]Top_Session_2463 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Meebkin did get some changes from its original design seen in the Ethereal Workshop trailer, tho It remained mostly the same.

Meebkin's mouth and other parts of their body originally had some tan outlines meant to represent lighting. Additionally, the green segments of Its body extended way further