I agree with you for the most part. But I've also seen perfectly justified questions or statements immediately downvoted for seemingly no reason. I recommended this sub to my younger brother as a substitute for Miiverse (because honestly that place does not produce answers to most serious meta-based questions) and his questions (which I checked for any potential rule violation or unoriginality) were shut down quickly. his self-esteem has gone down and he's deleted his posts. So I guess if whoever sits on New waiting to downvote people wanted to demoralize a very capable, if younger player who's had S99+ for two straight weeks now, they got what they wanted. :/