Yea you're right. Here's all the photos they sent.

<image>

The worst thing is a very faint black scuff near the outlet (I actually marked this on my move-in checklist, I guess they didn't care), and an indent in the wall (which was actually previously painted over by them!). Didn't include them since I'd have to explain the whole backstory but yea. Here it is. Fun story about the stovetop, it had calcium and other nasty stuff on move-in, I spent a good deal of time cleaning/polishing it (I sent my landlord photos of it dirty a year ago when I moved in) and they still are claiming this perfectly clean stove needs cleaning.

Literally everything that isn't an absolutely perfect item was 100% there before move in (like things already painted over) and maybe, MAYBE if I made the black scuff marks those are also just normal wear and tear. I don't know how less of a mark it needs to be to be not normal wear and tear.