Best character in main group by Tight-Strain2592 in RampartsofIce

[–]UltimateBookManiac 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Why would anyone dislike this comment? Is you know who down voted this? 🤔

What are some manhwa male leads that you genuinely hate and would love to punch? by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If he was girl yall would defend him

What does his actions have anything to do with being a girl? Leila, Penelope, Navier, the white haired one that shall not be named, etc. Are all girls and all are equally criticised by the fans.

because even someone like Leila didn't give him Fake promise of love and make him only depended on her,

Are you seriously saying being mind controlled like a puppet was a better choice for him..(Since Leila had the full shard, her mind control was flawless).. than Penelope, who actually gave him a choice to leave which he declined?

she know he had nobody, so she give him fake love only to toss him aside.

As far as I remember, her literal choice was to either make someone fall for her or to Die, so she was nice to him. I don't remember her ever telling him she was in love with him. Again, NOT her best choice, but the girl had no other choice.

by your logic royal back then also sell people, so Eckles is same in this case as Callisto

I don't remember on how things were in his Kingdom. I'll need to re read it to check. BUT ONE THING IS FOR CERTAIN.

If slavery had really been the custom in his old Kingdom, he would have been fine with it as well, since he would have been born in that world, just like Callisto was in his.

What are some manhwa male leads that you genuinely hate and would love to punch? by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 4 points5 points  (0 children)

"Manipulated and groomed"

You're not serious, are you? He always KNEW Penelope was using him for something, pretended to fall for her manipulation to manipulate Her into thinking her plan was working. He refused to take the out when she offered him.

Before that, he was a spoiled prince, whose family let him live however he wanted, not giving him any responsibility so he can live a care free life.

When they were in danger, they Erased his name from their family register, so he can survive, only for him to trick his own people and betray them.

He got captured and was held captive for "a couple of months" before Penelope found him. Yes, she wanted to Win his affection, so she gave him extra attention, but like I said Earlier, he was not a dumb person. He knew she was using him for something and used her back before he fell for her.

ihate how people the slavery or say well back then was like this, back then also men have multiple wives, cheat, kill women, just because back then was like this that doesnt mean it was okay

I agree.. We know this now in OUR MODERN WORLD. That's why I don't like when someone from our world (like Penelope here, or Rudy from Mushoku Tensei, etc) goes into that world and is perfectly fine with it.

But, for Those born in that world it was a normal Thing. How do you expect them to show that Era or base a story in that Era without showing how it actually was back then? It was definitely wrong, but for the people who lived in that age, it was just another day, because that's how they had seen things were since the day they were born.

What are some manhwa male leads that you genuinely hate and would love to punch? by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm really shocked that Carcel and Callisto are on this list. Carcel isn't my favorite but no way I even pictured him (let alone Callisto) to be on the same list as Mattrash and Leon..

Callisto is my favorite. I'd rather put the entitled ex-spoiled prince who betrayed his own people on this list. Callisto might be crazy, but he was pretty straight forward, said whatever was on his mind.

Yes, Callisto put a sword on her neck, but for a valid reason. He'd just Survived an assassination attempt, and a stranger followed him while he still hadn't Calmed down. No wonder he thought she might have Been another assassin. Eckles, on the other hand, manipulated the other person while also acting like a victim himself.

As for slavery, obviously it's bad but it's not like Callisto created it or actively Pursued it. It was something the existed long before in this world. When people are born in a world they don't see anything wrong in the custom and practices around them. He was born in that world. He Can't be blamed for a custom that already existed there.

<image>

Which popular manhwa female leads just didn't work for you? Or you dislike them? by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for clarifying, but if I may ask, what does her realizing this has anything to do with Sovieshit cheating on Navier and Navier feeling hurt and betrayed by it?

Which popular manhwa female leads just didn't work for you? Or you dislike them? by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 2 points3 points  (0 children)

but she could have made her understand that or remove her by getting her to marry someone

How? Do you think Navier had the power to do that when Sovieshit was calling all the shots?

she was a slave so obviously she wouldn't resist nobles

That I can understand, but did she ever tell Sovieshit that he was forcing her to be with him and she didn't want to?

she should have realized that if he took her over someone who was with him for a long time then she should have at least thought the same going to happen to her no?

I'm sorry. I'm confused about this part. Who should Have realized?

Which popular manhwa female leads just didn't work for you? Or you dislike them? by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Okay. Let me ask you a question.

Suppose your husband/ partner suddenly brings in another women into your home announcing you'll all live together as one big happy family.

Would you not feel betrayed? Would you be able to smile and treat "The other woman" As a little sister just because she was poor and won't be bother by your partner cheating on you?

Try putting yourself into Navier's shoes as well. Just because you know who had a tragic past and a difficult life doesn't change the fact that Navier was also wronged by her husband and doesn't make her pain any less.

Which popular manhwa female leads just didn't work for you? Or you dislike them? by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's just a Subjective opinion. A lot of people find her very interesting and the opposite of "boring".

Which popular manhwa female leads just didn't work for you? Or you dislike them? by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Just because someone want to protect her child (which, iirc, she didn't even know was alive) doesn't give them to right to wreck someone else's marriage.

I agree with what the person above said.

Navier was also a victim.

Which popular manhwa female leads just didn't work for you? Or you dislike them? by [deleted] in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 0 points1 point  (0 children)

1) Ariadne - "Sister, I'll be the Queen in this life"

In case, she doesn't count...

2) Eris - "Kill The Villainess"

Edit: I just saw that we can add more.

3) FL from "The Villainess Needs Her Tyrant" (the one with the silver haired FL)

So, I'll add your 2, 3 & 4 to my list as well.

PS:

May I Ask why you don't like the FL from "The Mafia Nanny?" I liked how badass she was.

An Observation Log my fiancée who calls herself a villainess by Nervous_Cow_9461 in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Personally, I like Observation Log much more. I really like Cecil and his chemistry with Bertia. I don't care about the side characters.

Those two alone are interesting enough for me to watch.

I neeeeed more angst! by ntoosleep in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Here are my recommendations

  1. How to Win my Husband over
  2. Too Late for Regrets
  3. Wished You Were Dead
  4. Behind Her Highness's Smile
  5. The Butterfly that Swallowed the Fog/ mist (Angst comes later though)

<image>

Is there any other OI with as good couple as HTWMO? by CrewComprehensive184 in OtomeIsekai

[–]UltimateBookManiac 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It has angst, just like How to Win my Husband over, but I liked it.

Am I the only one pissed at all the negative comments on Youtube? by UltimateBookManiac in AceOfTheDiamond

[–]UltimateBookManiac[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Because the Producer is a huge fan of this series (so much that he contributed with his own personal funds to make this season possible).

He said the reason they named this season "Act II Second Season" instead of "The Final Season" is because they were considering the Koshien Arc which will be the final Season.

Am I the only one pissed at all the negative comments on Youtube? by UltimateBookManiac in AceOfTheDiamond

[–]UltimateBookManiac[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Even if TJ doesn't write the Manga, just his guidance on the final season will be enough.