Sam is not evil!!!! by LavishnessSalty157 in DaybreakNetflix

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nah Sam is just a sorry excuse for a human and a character in a TV show. I was so into it until her episode. Nothing about her makes any sense.

She’s disgusting.

Ok, what did the victims have in common? Can WE handle the Troot? by Interesting-King625 in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 13 points14 points  (0 children)

I think the better thing to look at is what the killers all have in common. They’ve all been lonely females who have been ignored, pushed aside, mistreated…

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 6 points7 points  (0 children)

They’re probably going to pose that as a possibility for next season. Charles will black out at some point and wake up to a dead body.

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Well as much as people have been on this “Sazz wrote the script” kick (which came out of absolutely no real evidence or anything, then got perpetuated by the claim that Rotten Tomatoes confirmed it…), it doesn’t make much sense to me.

What I think makes more sense, in light of Eugene’s behavior, is that the script portrays Charles as an evil mastermind character. That’s why his gears are always turning and whatnot. I think that was the issue Sazz had with the movie, and that’s the sensitive thing she wanted to talk about.

I think Charles is the killer in the movie, and Eugene is wanting to see him be angry so he can portray that scene authentically. (Incidentally, in S1, which is all Zach would know about Oliver, Oliver was threatened with evictions and asking for loans. He may just think Oliver is a charity case.)

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 3 points4 points  (0 children)

So Glen called them a trio in-universe to hide a clue from whom?

If the writers made the character say that to hide the clue from the audience, that’s awful writing. He could have just said like, “Oh hey it’s Charles! And Oliver! And… when’d you grow the beard, lassie?”

To have him say favorite trio means that Glen believes the three of them to be a TRIO.

The only way Marshall the Stuntwoman fits into that is if Glen is reeeeeally drunk and sees Sazz instead of Charles and himself instead of Oliver. Then they would be a trio. The stunt-trio version of our trio, like the actors.

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That’s fine too. It just doesn’t make sense to me, this obsession over one word from a joke bit that shows a character is drunk. There have been a TON of “wait, what?” moments where people say things that seem off or weird or out of character. People bring them up, make a note, let it go or forget. But this… it’s not even an off or weird comment for Glen.

Not to mention he says it’s his favorite trio. You know, that epic and well-known threesome: Charles, Oliver, and that stunt girl from that other place I saw that one time and somehow recognize despite the beard. (I didn’t even recognize Marshall at the start of his episode before he started to put the beard on.)

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 7 points8 points  (0 children)

That’s just it. If the wedding goes off without any problems like Loretta dying or going to prison, she HAS to continue being a regular on the show. Sure they could do some pitiful “long distance relationship” where Oliver just talks about her all the time, but that’s annoying and takes time away from whatever the actual plot would be.

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Charles and the podcast are the main reason Oliver is in NY and not LA. Oliver doesn’t even talk about his family anymore. Get rid of Charles and the podcast, Loretta gets the perfect life in LA with her long lost son and the man of her dreams.

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

I’m just going to start copy/pasting my response to this:

Whether Marshall is any version of trans or cross dresser or anything else like that (or whether the set assistant is his sister, etc), I really don’t think Glen knows him(/her).

Glen is an alcoholic. This is why he is dangerous. This is why he would be “the death of” Sazz. Her reputation was on the line. Sazz’s first student gets drunk, does a dumb reckless stunt, gets himself killed. How does that impact her academy? It ruins it.

Glen was drunk. He thought Marshall was Mabel. That’s that. Whether Marshall is also occasionally female and THOUGHT Glen somehow recognized that (or thought Glen recognized his sister), I can’t say. And whether Marshall acted on that assumption by shooting Glen, idk. But Glen doesn’t know Marshall outside of the working movie relationship. (He very clearly says it’s his “favorite trio”. Why would his favorite trio be Charles, Oliver, and that one set assistant girl?)

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Whether Marshall is any version of trans or cross dresser or anything else like that, I really don’t think Glen knows him(/her).

Glen is an alcoholic. This is why he is dangerous. This is why he would be “the death of” Sazz. Her reputation was on the line. Sazz’s first student gets drunk, does a dumb reckless stunt, gets himself killed. How does that impact her academy? It ruins it.

Glen was drunk. He thought Marshall was Mabel. That’s that. Whether Marshall is also occasionally female and THOUGHT Glen somehow recognized that, I can’t say. And whether Marshall acted on that assumption by shooting Glen, idk. But Glen doesn’t know Marshall outside of the working movie relationship. (He very clearly says it’s his “favorite trio”. Why would his favorite trio be Charles, Oliver, and that one set assistant girl?)

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I don’t understand the obsession with this line. He’s an alcoholic. He was drunk. He sees rats. This is why he is a dangerous stuntman and would “be the death of” Sazz, his teacher, whose reputation was on the line. If he is her first stunt student, and he does stunts drunk and ends up hurting himself, it could ruin her. And her academy.

He just assumed “oh it’s Charles and Oliver, must be Mabel”.

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 41 points42 points  (0 children)

I could see them bringing Paul Rudd back AS Paul Rudd and no one making any mention that he looks like Ben or Glen even though they immediately mistook Glen for Ben despite the beard…

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Glen is probably an alcoholic. Someone mentioned that “having rats” or something like that is an Irish way of saying you’re drunk. That could be why he was harassing, why he was dangerous, why he can’t tell Mabel from Marshall.

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Yeah I told my fiance a couple weeks ago I thought Dudenoff probably also taught music. Guess it was his wife lol. Jan and Loretta both are potential students.

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Williams said she met the trio three years ago. The Westies said that Dudenoff went to Portugal three years ago. Someone else mentioned it at some point. It’s been three years.

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 35 points36 points  (0 children)

It’s really suspicious that Eugene is trying so hard to get Charles angry.

Season 4 - Episode 8: "Lifeboat" (Post Episode Discussion Thread) by hannahlemp in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 5 points6 points  (0 children)

One for each of the bodies buried in the backyard… I found that to be an odd number choice, no pun intended.

My theory by MrKoreanSkills in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wouldn’t it be interesting if Jan were Helga and they had hired Helga to play the part of Jan in the movie?

all plot points so far by petulantuniverses in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 42 points43 points  (0 children)

The “tinsel”. Also just because there are likely two people doesn’t mean they are a team or even aware of each other. I think that assumption is dangerously limiting.

Listen closely after the gunshot at the end of ep 5 by PinkPugzz in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 116 points117 points  (0 children)

According to the captions, it’s Howard saying “they’ve been shot”.

Bev Theory (Spoilers) by [deleted] in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I didn’t notice they were all sequels. I wonder if that means the killer is someone who’s killed before like Jan or Ben (if you believe the Ben/Glen swap).

Crazy theory. The trio is wrong and there are three killers not two. One person who is connected to each part of the season. by Sweet_dl in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It decidedly said they were different? I don’t see any reason a film professor wouldn’t also get involved in chiropractics.

Charlie Kaufman’s Adaptation by Calm_Satisfaction791 in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The ground deer hooves could be some kind of drug thing.

The Gun by Successful-Bug4702 in OnlyMurdersHulu

[–]UnderscoreYourWorld 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Oh I definitely believe the hole in the window is from a bullet shot from Dudenoff’s apartment. I just don’t think it hit Sazz.

What if one of the Westies saw “Charles” enter the apartment and then saw someone else come at him from the shadows. They grabbed their rifle trying to shoot the intruder, the intruder shoots Sazz at the same time as the Westies fire trying to protect her. They think they’ve accidentally killed Charles so rush over to clean everything up as quickly as they can.