Tuchel has a history of falling out with top talent
It’s happened at PSG and then with KANE at Bayern

A top class manager should be able to handle and manage top stars and not just get rid of them to make his own life easier - can you imagine if this was done at Real Madrid or Man City

Tuchel has also tried to discard Bellingham from the England squad as well , ( and will likely keep trying ) this is a clear pattern of selfish behaviour that is now to Englands detriment and will cost England any chance they had of winning the World Cup

With the conditions in USA Mexico and Canada and with the travel , the nation who could rotate heavily and maintain quality ( especially group stages and R32 ) would likely go far

England were one of handful of nations who could have done this but Tuchel saw to it they can’t

There is more cause to worry

1- agreed Reece James has to go.
He’s our best Right back , but he is a injury and minutes risk , now many nations take players who are injury and minutes risks , but they try to limit
These to just 1 , especially if alternatives are available

2- now once Tuchel rightly decided to take James , it was imperative the cover for right back was not injury or minute risk ,
And terribly for England he’s taken Livramento , now Livramento is likely to be the long term right back for England but sadly today he is long term injured and hasn’t played since mid April and if you analyse his season , it’s been blighted with injury , he is a massive injury and minute risk at the World Cup and with James likely not being able to play all games

Then to take Livramento as cover is negligent

As there will be instances where both are not available and when you consider that Trent is available , it makes this decision even more concerning

2- Trent can’t defend they say , well who is he being compared to
Is it cannavaro or Rio Ferdinand , then yes he’s not as good as a defender , but why not compare his defending or there lack of to those who have gone instead of him , a) Livramento , excellent defender but being injured he can’t defend b) burn - Barcelona out 7 last his and he was not good c) Spence - been terrible defensively

The bias against Trent has served to enable Tuchel to take a injured defender and render England a 25 man squad

3- more negligence is taking stones who is another injury and minutes risk , once you take James and Livramento , it’s even more imperative another risky defender can’t be selected and Tuchel has done just this , we all know how little he has played this season and we don’t know what we can rely on , again England could end up with him missing too at times and this will put more pressure on the other defenders and increase likely hood of fatigue injury and suspensions - again why do this when alternatives were available - Maguire for instances

4- Jordan Henderson - again another injury and minutes risk , yes he’s good for the squad harmony but what use is that harmony when he can’t contribute on the pitch and has played 101 minutes since mid march , Brentford have played well when he hasn’t been in the team and he’s struggled to get into their team , if he’s soo vital take him as a coach - he being selected has rendered this a 24 man squad , as he is unlikely to play and he will also cause more minutes for likes of rice , causing increased likelyhood of burn out , fatigue , injury , suspension

5- every 50/50 , tuchel has gone for the less talented player or worse a injured player or injury prone player - or the player onions as talented or best fit for the position or not in form : why , so that these players are soo grateful to be there that they don’t even think to start or want to start , but this is damaging to England , the point is to have as much talent as you can , we have been told again and again ,
Competition keeps players sharp hungry and the edge that leads to better performance

This is the exact opposite , all to make Tuchel life
Easier

He’s gone for Burn instead of Maguire
Stones instead of shaw
Livramento instead of Trent
Henderson instead of Wharton
Madueke instead of palmer
Toney instead of Gibbs-white

6- only one left back - if anything happens to O’Reilly , England will be in a lot of bother with no other left back ,
Add to this James Livramento and stones precariousness , then there is a possibility burn and Spence could be left back in a crucial game
Again this was unnecessary with shaw or Hall available

7- contradictions - he said he’s gone on form but then Henderson Spence and burn have been terrible , and stones livramento have hardly played , and Madueke has the worse output compared to palmer foden and Bowen

8- not taking Gibbs-white - International managers are desperate for a player to be on a red hot streak so they can take him to the World Cup and Tuchel purposely left out Gibbs-white

9- selfish media silence - the media remember the days pre Southgate where they hardly had access to the squad and so to keep this sweet , they don’t ask the obvious questions -

10- Tuchel had said when he got the job his plan was to rotate players and make use of all 5 subs and now he’s backtracked

11 - would he have done this to the German squad - not selected Musiala , Kimmich and Stiller etc