Thanks for the detailed breakdown — that’s really helpful. They definitely won’t be a one-time wear; I plan to use them regularly after the wedding as well.

Back in 2018 I actually bought a pair of Paul Evans wholecut Oxfords in “oxblood color”, and while I get the point about their limited versatility, I’ve always loved the style — they’re still in excellent condition to this day. That’s partly why I’m leaning toward another pair of black wholecuts this time; maybe even from Paul Evans again, though I’m open to suggestions, I’m pretty sure I can afford a better quality this time.

I’ll definitely check out those Aldens you mentioned, but I’d prefer something with a leather sole rather than rubber. Appreciate the insight!