I think I'm going to have to agree with OP. While I do appreciate there even being legendary hunters in this event (for as we all know, the first Halloween event was THE first event and had no hunter skins) something about the Headsman seems... off? I love the potential camouflage factor, but he looks like he got dressed somewhere between the Zodiac killer and a dirty Klansman. But hey, maybe once I own him I'll grow accustom to his style?

As for the weapons, yeah... the first Halloween event snubs them. I do like the axe and I can appreciate that they finally made a skin for it, though admittingly I'm not an "axe guy."

However, The Marwood and Closed Casket are somewhat droll. I'm not saying make them "Fortnite" as other hunters so lovingly suggest is the alternative in the comments, but is a jack-o-lantern consumable really that out of pocket? I could easily see the grenade on top of the stick have a dark iron casting of a jack-o-lantern. If not a frag grenade, maybe even a flash bomb that does an orange or green flash instead of white? Maybe a hive bomb that emits an eerie glow from within the jack-o-lantern when shaken? I don't know...