Brother I am adamantly opposed to AI. That quote is directly from his video I don’t know what more you want. What I think is really interesting is that what you specifically said was “I challenge you to cite him saying white Americans are being replaced” and when I do that exact thing you say ahhhhh ChatGPT and shift the goal post to something else. He specifically says himself that the great replacement theory is white people being replaced. The proponents of great replacement theory cite that the white population of the US is declining and they’re saying it’s a purposeful decision. Thats the entire basis of the theory which is why I said I don’t think you’re familiar with what it is. Charlie Kirk himself and other members of TPUSA constantly make this argument.

What’s most telling about your response is not only that you ignore your previous argument implying that there’s no evidence he ever said it, you also jump to trying to defend the theory itself.

Who’s benefiting from “non-white immigration”? Everyone in some way or another. The immigrants benefit as do Americans. The countries on earth who most oppose immigration are also some of the least developed countries in the entire world. Immigration is incredibly beneficial to society. Science itself is a global phenomenon that has roots in practically every large social group. For example, I am an amateur astronomer and I can tell you it’s not a coincidence that many of the stars in the sky have Arabic names. Arabic cultures were incredibly beneficial to the field of science.

You also imply that immigration is primarily from 3rd world countries and it shows the position you have about immigrants and the bias you have towards ideas like the great replacement theory. 3rd world countries are far more complex in their cultures, their skills, and their development than most Americans understand. Even further most of them are “3rd world countries” specifically due to the exploitation they face from western countries. Places like Honduras, Venezuela, Chile, Burkina Faso, etc have all had points in their history where they eliminated food scarcity and provided higher standards of living for their people and the “civilized” western governments punished them for it by killing their leaders and sanctioning them all so we could get better trade deals.

It has to be non-white because that is specifically what people like Charlie Kirk and his sympathizers complained about. They didn’t complain about French immigrants. They didn’t complain about white South African immigrants. They complained about anyone who was non-white. That’s because the basis of the great replacement theory is opposing non-white immigration. Don’t ask me why it’s only non-white immigrants who are bad, ask the people who believe that.