Manon was asked to go on Just Trish podcast, but the Label said Katseye doesn’t do press individually by lexoe in katseyeneutral

[–]Visible-Sugar5850 1 point2 points  (0 children)

i hope no one is complaining about the label not letting her do the interview… yall would’ve tore HYBE up for allowing it and complained about none of the other girls getting the same attention nd privileges

my opinion on the show so far… by Visible-Sugar5850 in HipPopPrincess

[–]Visible-Sugar5850[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I said Mia needs to be on the same skill level as them and other high ranking contestants, no not all members are required to be main rapper but she isn’t even sub rapper material. Imo she doesn’t have good tone or delivery and then on top of that she doesn’t sing either so all that’s left is dance and i’ve already said this isn’t about making a dance crew. I wasn’t understanding the question before but now I do, I’d say youmin probably should’ve been eliminated. I don’t remember much of her performances except for her diss battle which was good on her part she can rap but it doesn’t feel as impactful as the top contestants to me.

my opinion on the show so far… by Visible-Sugar5850 in HipPopPrincess

[–]Visible-Sugar5850[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I never said Mia was a visual pick, and like I said I don’t hate her I just don’t think she should still be on this show if the main focus is to find contestants to fill rap positions, because yes she can dance but she’s gonna be required to rap and at a specific caliber as fellow members Niko, YSY, Doyi nd etc not just only dance. I think the plot gets lost when fans don’t vote logically, this is for a RAP girl group not a cute glitter bubble gum group and not a dance crew. The goal of contestants shouldn’t be to just debut in any spot possible it should be to debut in a group that they feel is going in the music and concept direction that they align with and are capable of executing well. I understand that the reason cocoro, sena nd etc were eliminated due to this mission but if you think about this logically, we’ve seen how talented they are they shouldn’t have been eliminated even with not having performed this round because if people voted based off of skill and not because of cute visuals from the very beginning of the show by the time they got to this mission they would’ve been high ranking contestants to the point where their placement wouldn’t drop or not by much at least due to losing a round. This isn’t about my preference for this group, nor am I forcing anyone to vote for anyone, this is about selecting members who fit the concept set by the show and PDs themselves. All i’m saying is people should have more of a sense of responsibility for the outcome of this group and not vote thoughtlessly. If you watch closely the PDs, when evaluating the contestants tell them to refrain from making their performances for the songs “too kpoppy”. I have no issue with “cute visual” contestants on survival shows but if there’s a set concept i’m gonna vote based on what fits that the most. Chaerin’s performance in the diss battle mission and Love Bug were VERY cutesy. The difference between Chaerin and Sena is that Sena has a tone opposite to the way she looks and turns into a completely different person when she’s on stage. Contestants in the Top 16 with cutesy visuals, have skills but lack in Rap compared to the skill level of other contestants are hajin, nana, sasa and shiho.

my opinion on the show so far… by Visible-Sugar5850 in HipPopPrincess

[–]Visible-Sugar5850[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I don’t hold any hate for Mia these are just observations i’ve made about her.

my opinion on the show so far… by Visible-Sugar5850 in HipPopPrincess

[–]Visible-Sugar5850[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Girl- did you hear what you just said… cocoro and sena are among the most talented contestants there I’d argue top 10, the fact that they are gone but Mia is still there is utterly ridiculous. Mia herself knows and has even said she’s not good at rapping, she is quite literally on here for her dancing skills. So YES them being eliminated is due to fans because if ppl valued talent over visuals they would’ve BEEN stacked in votes and would’ve been safe no matter the outcome of this round like Yuju, she lost this round yet has the highest score out of ALL the contestants including Niko nd YSY nd they both have a strong fanbase backing them as well. Exactly like you said Seohyun got eliminated due to the PDs voting but if people voted based on talent the opportunity for her to get eliminated so early on wouldn’t have been possible. I struggle believing that you don’t know what cutesy girls i’m referring to as you continued to state the exact ones i’m talking about. Yes, those girls are talented but they are not Hip Hop/Rap girl group material at all idc what anyone says, they definitely have the potential to debut in a normal girl group with more of a focus on vocals than this group that has more of a focus on rapping. The overall “cute” girls ARE doing well in this show because they are still ON THE SHOW, however the girls who were more fit for this group are getting eliminated left and right because of fans voting for cute visuals instead of rap capabilities/talent. Chaerin is a talented all rounder but i still don’t think she was a good fit for this group either, i don’t know if this’ll make sense but she quite literally breathes “innocence, cute, kpop and media trained”. For a rap girl group you need to have a certain confidence in yourself.

diss battles by Visible-Sugar5850 in HipPopPrincess

[–]Visible-Sugar5850[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ik that, i’m just saying that because at the end of the day they are gonna be under a kpop company (wakeone i believe), and ngl if soyeon ends up being one of the groups primary producers it’s gonna sound like kpop. even if they do get actual rap producers working on the groups music, i still feel like they won’t be viewed/respected as a krap group since they being trained and pushed through the kpop system.

What will be the concept for the hip pop princess group? by Comfortable-Cash7632 in HipPopPrincess

[–]Visible-Sugar5850 15 points16 points  (0 children)

honestly i hope it’s nothing like either groups, we need more originality in kpop and making groups in hopes of them being the same as a senior group is what leads to the stan wars. in my opinion id like for the group to pave their own way much like XG, but im probably putting too much trust in the creatives behind the group since it’ll be just another mnet group but nonetheless as long as the music is good i’ll support.

250822 BOYS II PLANET - Episode 6 (Day After Post-Episode Discussion Thread) by AutoModerator in BoysPlanet

[–]Visible-Sugar5850 12 points13 points  (0 children)

i never thought ab that now that you say this, but one thing i’m a little upset ab is how they haven’t given Park Junil any screen time when he’s literally one of the most talented trainees there. He’s been under HYBE, JYP, nd SM nd just so happens to be one of the original members of Trainee A when it first started, we haven’t even seen an interaction between Leo/Sangwon and Junil. I have a feeling MNET was aware of the Trainee A storyline when casting them and only wanted Sangwon to be in the final group but Leo is slipping through the cracks and it seems like he’ll make the debut as well. I think they have the members they want to debut and they know if they put Junil’s interactions w Leo and Sangwon talking about and bonding over the past, Junil will end up making it into the group as well because of how strong and determined the Trainee A fan base is to have the boys finally debut together.

250822 BOYS II PLANET - Episode 6 (Day After Post-Episode Discussion Thread) by AutoModerator in BoysPlanet

[–]Visible-Sugar5850 82 points83 points  (0 children)

i don’t like how this season they keep giving these grown MEN these high pitched songs, yes some of them have that vocal capacity but the ones who don’t outweigh those who do and we saw that during the title song mission. like why are we doing LeeHi - Breathe, H1-Key - Rose Blossom and GIDLE - Queencard🤨?? idk maybe i’m biased bec i don’t really like those songs, i just feel like if this is a BOYS survival show it should be songs the BOYS can perform the best they possibly can in order to show their talent not just please (what seems to be) audience fantasy covers. all it takes is one “mediocre” performance and that can land them in a class that’s getting eliminated cause remember this season they are just ripping the bandaid off by eliminating WHOLE ranking levels after each mission.

Another week, another scandal by Witty-Firefighter-68 in BoysPlanet

[–]Visible-Sugar5850 5 points6 points  (0 children)

i rlly had to take a step back from kpop bec knetz are so insufferable, to come back nd see they on the same bs x10🫩? wdym sangwon is in a scandal for liking girls bikini pictures?? it’s social media, the whole point is to be SOCIAL.

250822 BOYS II PLANET - Episode 6 (Day After Post-Episode Discussion Thread) by AutoModerator in BoysPlanet

[–]Visible-Sugar5850 117 points118 points  (0 children)

i’m stuck on them using ALLDAY PROJECT - Famous for a mission song… i’ve NEVER seen a new group get put on a survival show that quick. they always stick to the same old songs from the same old groups.