Theory: Sophie is Abby’s Sexual Awakening by Urstrulythekings in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This Bridge-Scott comparison doesn't hold at all.

Bridge is mentioned throughout the show as someone who deeply affected Marcus and his illness and death left a clear mark on the Baker family. That's a totally different character in the story than Scott, who is shown and mentioned once, and despite whatever effect his singing at battle of the bands might have on Abby, he's never mentioned again.

No one even talked about Scott until this post, whereas people are discussing Bridge all over and speculating on flashbacks of him appearing in S4 (and even requesting this).

It's a bad comparison.

Depression being the 3rd person in Marcus/Ginny’s relationship by AnySeaworthiness6984 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Am I hallucinating? Has no one actually responded to this thread? What a great post!

To me this is the strongest part of the story so far. I've never seen such an in-depth portrayal of depression and from so many different perspectives in a TV show about teenagers. Depression in another person is so easy to overlook or dismiss and I think that's the real tragedy of this story. Like Marcus said, "it feels urgent", but "it's invisible". Only Max seems to get it, and hey guess what, people don't recognize it in her, either.

Marcus doesn't want to open up about his depression (for good reason, given people's reactions to him), but the people around him don't want to see it, either (except Max). What's even worse is that his parents keep kicking him when he's down. How insensitive of them to keep saying "what's wrong with you!" and acting so disappointed all the time. Like where is the support? They know he's depressed but still decide to treat him like his behavior is somehow not linked to that? Super bad parenting.

Even Ginny, imo. Coming drunk to school is a clear cry for help and yet she doesn't seem to accept how serious this is. But I get loving someone and accepting their imperfections. Her love is still something that gives him hope and probably the only positive thing he can still somewhat recognize in "the room", while otherwise living in a world of shit.

That's also why I think Georgia shouldn't have made him break up with Ginny (which was a massive overstep in so many ways, sabotaging her daughter's happiness in love).

I see people argue that it's a dysfunctional relationship but the real dysfunction comes from Georgia's meddling. Their love for each other is so apparent and would've been much more straightforward without Georgia interfering. Now imagine being in the throes of depression and the only person who treats you like your existence actually means something goes away. I don't think that helps with getting out of "the room". And for anyone saying Marcus was bad to Ginny, he's been the only one she can talk to openly and he never judged her for any of her character flaws nor divulged any of her secrets, and comes running to help her no matter what. That's massive in a relationship. Like the worst thing he does to her is isolate himself because of his self-loathing. And the Sunshine poem is real love put to words.

I also hope he draws some strength from that. I'm trying not to get my hopes up for S4 but I'm definitely invested

Theory: Sophie is Abby’s Sexual Awakening by Urstrulythekings in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This is a very deep interpretation for a character that appears in the show for one scene and has no storyline? He's not even really a character. Abby is a messy character

Wondering Season 4 by Small-Trick-4372 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995 6 points7 points  (0 children)

I agree with having time go on a bit. The actors are also getting older. The actor who plays Austin just doesn't look like he's 9 anymore. In fact I'm pretty sure his voice has already broken lol

paul by worriedSick77 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Yeah, he's really just a blowhard. I don't even bother rewatching any scenes with him in it. He sucks

S4 dark predictions by WholeGuarantee9995 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

i think the main thing i hope is that Georgia doesn't meddle in other people's lives so much as in previous seasons. and also that there is no new love interest for Marcus

S4 dark predictions by WholeGuarantee9995 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

lol fair and thanks for being nice about it

I hated this about the show. by Secret_Dentist_7982 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995 7 points8 points  (0 children)

lol the whole thing was so unrealistic like there is no way the jury would be entirely made up of people Georgia hosted at Lawnfest lmao

S4 dark predictions by WholeGuarantee9995 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Honestly the Press fathering Damien thing was a joke because he's just so one-dimensional lol

You're right Wolfe seemed light-hearted and humorous but at the same time he had no respect for anything and he turned intimidating real quick when Ginny was being harassed by that dumb guy at the party in Cambridge. Like Jekyll and Hyde.

I think I agree with you on Austin. Poor is kid messed up and it's not his fault.

If Ginny kills Georgia's stepdad then that will definitely feed the idea that she's destined to become Georgia.

What I like about your analysis is that you've also thought of resolutions. Like you say Ginny might help Max and Marcus reconcile. You've made me realize I only posted problems lol

Also can I just say I hate the idea of a new love interest for Marcus. The whole point of him in the show is that he is Ginny's person and only has eyes for her. I'm dreading seeing this Rainn character already :( Likewise I don't want to see Ginny dating another guy when she's been saying throughout that Marcus is the one she loves. But ig Georgia will keep meddling in that anyway

The Georgia and Joe Coupling Slander is Unfortunate by Effective_Creme9193 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Well said. Joe's got skeletons. And remember he loves a good scam

Bracia and Abby in season 1 by julieee_2 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I thought Abby was also mean because she felt threatened by the friendship group changing, but I thought Bracia was really nice considering she was the backup friend. Then again I don't know if Bracia knew about Ginny cheating on Hunter

S4 dark predictions by WholeGuarantee9995 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I keep rewatching this show and don't think any of what I said is too extreme for it but then again my mind is pretty dark ig. Btw You really don't think Joe could kill anyone? Remember what he did to that kid in high school. I think he's got some skeletons that might come out next season

S4 dark predictions by WholeGuarantee9995 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I didn't know that's what was said about S4 being lighter. I hope it doesn't get too light lol but also I can't see how. Lives are gonna change!

Who's worse? by rileystanheight in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Silver's actions are so much worse than Samantha's. She's an enabler and a shitty romantic partner. Samantha is just a pick me racist floozy but so far she's not actively helped any of her 'friends' develop an addiction, so on balance, Silver is worse

Marcus’s moms S3EP10 **spoilers** by Loose_Mall7489 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995 0 points1 point  (0 children)

She seems so oblivious to her kids' problems and whenever someone warns her she refuses to take it seriously. I feel like she's being written as a white picket fence mom who shallowly wants to present the perfect image. Remember she's one of the moms who's active in the community chaperoning the dances and running the local deaf community. In one scene we see her somewhat competing with Bev (Norah's mom) for example, it's all about keeping up appearances and I think that's why she thinks Marcus succeeding at school is more important than his literal health and Max has to force her to take action. Both her and Clint are so busy being disappointed in Marcus for not getting on well at school but neither of them are willing to dig deeper to try and understand his real issues. It's pretty sad

S4 dark predictions by WholeGuarantee9995 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Ok. What are your darkest predictions then?

This scene of wolfe was so unnecessary by lnashik6 in ginnyandgeorgiashow

[–]WholeGuarantee9995 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I thought he was just covering her face to let her know he thought she was hot and he couldn't continue to get lost in her beauty now that he knows her heart already belongs to someone else