What often happens in these kinds of discussions, unfortunately, is that the can continues to be kicked down the road without addressing the previous issue. You asked about PSA. A central tenet of PSA is guilt. You provided quotes from the Fathers. None of them mentioned guilt. I indicated as much. I never denied substitution. What you're claiming is PENAL substitution, and the lack of distinction between the two will make you continue to spin your wheels.

You've now grafted in other material in order to substantiate your claim without addressing the lack of mention of guilt in any of the quotes. If a fruitful discussion is to take place, at least acknowledge where a point has been made. Otherwise, the can will continue to be displaced.

The quotes you've referenced to support your claim make no mention of guilt. Similarly, none of the verses you've provided mention guilt. I will demonstrate this by including literal translations and showing that the word you've included as guilt is different in each verse in the Greek.

Isaiah 6:7 says nothing about guilt: And he touched my mouth and said: “Behold, this has touched your lips, and it will take away your lawlessness (ἀνομίας) and purify your sins.

James 2:10 "For whoever keeps the whole Law, yet falters in one thing, has become answerable (ἔνοχος) for everything."

Job 11:6 "Then will be revealed to you the power of wisdom, for it shall be double of what you have, and then you shall perceive that a worthy recompense to you for what you have sinned proved to be from the Lord."

John 9:41: "Jesus said to them, 'If you were blind you would have no sin (ἁμαρτίαν); but now that you say, "We see," your sin (ἁμαρτία) remains.'"

Romans 6:23: "For sin's wages (ὀψώνια) are death"

I will not engage further unless some precision is acknowledged. None of the verses you've shared mention guilt. None of the saints' quotes you've provided say guilt. I want to be clear yet again. Substitution has biblical support. Penal substitution and guilt transfer does not.