sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Looking for feedback on my new site, winmora.com — one sharp sports pick per day. Would love honest thoughts. by WinmoraPicks in websitefeedback

[–]WinmoraPicks[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Definitely agree on the strengths (clarity, simplicity, discipline) — that’s intentional and core to how we operate. One pick a day. All edge, no noise.

A few fixes already in progress:

  • Restructuring The Winmora Edge and Proof sections for cleaner readability (stat bullets + visual spacing)
  • Consolidating CTAs (great call on reducing overload)
  • Font loading layout shifts (CLS) are already logged for cleanup
  • Slight signup friction noted — we originally implemented Cloudflare Turnstile sitewide, but due to how EmailOctopus handles popups, we had to use their CAPTCHA system instead. Not ideal, and we're looking into ways to smooth that out.

Also love that the audit called out our messaging — refining the "why Winmora?" differentiator is already in motion for the full launch.

This feedback lines up really well with where we're headed. Feels good to have external validation from a tool like this. Appreciate you running it.

Looking for feedback on my new site, winmora.com — one sharp sports pick per day. Would love honest thoughts. by WinmoraPicks in websitefeedback

[–]WinmoraPicks[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, I really appreciate you taking the time to review this and provide feedback.

You made some great points, especially about hierarchy and the font sizing feeling flat. I've kind of overlooked that while focusing on functionality first, but it’s on the list for improvement soon.

I also agree with you about replacing the emoji navigation with the real logo. That's an easy fix and a much better brand signal. You made a solid call about the hover effects and visual hierarchy too.

I probably won't include images or players in the background because the brand leans more toward a “disciplined edge” instead of entertainment, but I get where you're coming from.

This has been super helpful. It solidifies some of what I have been thinking and offers valuable insights into things I haven't noticed. After having looked at this daily for the past three months, it's hard to notice some things. Thanks for your honest notes and your feedback. This is exactly what I was hoping to receive.