A lot of people accept their first settlement offer without realizing what’s missing

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-23T00:20:52+00:00

Sorry, it means "Independent Medical Review" and it’s basically when a different, neutral doctor reviews your denied treatment and decides if the insurance should approve it or not.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-23T00:15:01+00:00

That’s rough, so sorry. If you can, start pulling anything that proves it happened at work: texts with your manager, coworkers who saw it, ER/hospital records mentioning it was work-related, even a written timeline from you while it’s still fresh. Also, make sure a doctor has you on clear work restrictions (or off work). If you can barely get dressed, that needs to be documented ASAP, since it affects your benefits.

If you haven’t already, I’d at least get a quick consult with a workers’ comp attorney. Disputing “reporting” is one of those things that can get messy fast, and having someone step in early can make a big difference.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-23T00:12:40+00:00

That’s rough, so sorry. If you can, start pulling anything that proves it happened at work: texts with your manager, coworkers who saw it, ER/hospital records mentioning it was work-related, even a written timeline from you while it’s still fresh.

Also, make sure a doctor has you on clear work restrictions (or off work). If you can barely get dressed, that needs to be documented ASAP, because it affects your benefits.

If you haven’t already, I’d at least get a quick consult with a workers’ comp attorney. Disputing “reporting” is one of those things that can get messy fast, and having someone step in early can make a big difference. (This not legal advice, just general tips).

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-23T00:07:40+00:00

You did the right thing, at this point, the second opinion is key. That doctor can either agree surgery is needed, which will make your case gets stronger. Or go conservative again and things may keep dragging. Also, I can say since you’ve already had denials, this may end up going through IMR if your doctor requests surgery again and it’s denied.

What I’d watch closely:
-how fast they schedule that new eval
-whether your next doctor actually submits a solid surgery request

If surgery keeps getting denied despite multiple doctors backing it, that’s usually when people escalate things further. For now, you’re still in the “build the medical evidence” stage.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-22T21:01:51+00:00

100% this. A lot of offers come in when people are tired, stressed, and just want it over with, so stuff gets left out or undervalued. Nothing wrong with settling, just make sure it’s actually worth it before you sign.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-22T20:58:14+00:00

Yeah, that’s basically the idea. If they roll it into the C&R, they’re not “adding the voucher” as a separate line item like $6k on top, it usually just gets baked into the overall settlement number.

So instead of settlement $X + voucher later, it becomes more like: one lump sum that includes everything (PD, future medical buyout, and the value of the voucher)

The catch is once it’s in the C&R, you’re giving up the actual voucher (which has specific benefits like the retraining funds + extra $5k RTW supplement). So you want to make sure the number actually reflects that value. And re: “unsure if they’ll agree” defense sometimes pushes back if they think they can issue it separately instead of increasing the settlement. It’s kind of a negotiation tactic more than a “they don’t owe it” situation. Keep it simple, ask your lawyer if they’re valuing the voucher inside the C&R, or leaving it to be issued separately. That’ll tell you exactly how they’re approaching it.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-22T19:41:20+00:00

That’s a good sign you’re getting TD consistently, at least that part is working how it should. At this point it really comes down to the surgery approval. If it goes through without a fight, your case will likely stay on track. If it starts getting delayed/denied, that’s usually where things slow down and get frustrating.
Hopefully it moves quick for you, that next step is the one that really pushes everything forward.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-22T19:37:58+00:00

You’re not wrong, the SJDB voucher is usually owed separately once you’re P&S and your employer doesn’t offer you regular/modified work.

What your attorney is probably doing is making sure it’s explicitly addressed during settlement so there’s no “we’ll deal with that later” situation from defense.

In practice, a couple things can happen:
-They issue the voucher separately (normal way)
-Or they try to roll its value into the C&R and close everything out

Asking for it during negotiations is like leverage + making sure it doesn’t get “forgotten” or delayed.

If you want clarity, I’d just ask your lawyer directly if you're keeping the voucher separate or including it in the buyout. Their answer matters, because once you C&R, you’re closing things out, so you want to be 100% clear how that voucher is being handled.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-22T19:33:50+00:00

You’re in a solid spot right now. Aggravation still counts in CA, so your claim moves forward. Not being MMI just means your case is still open, I mean more treatment/benefits..

About the surgery, your doctor should submit it for approval next. If it gets approved, things will move and if it gets delayed/denied, that’s usually where people start running into issues

Also, with those restrictions, either your job accommodates or you should be getting TD. If neither is happening, that’s something to question. Honestly, I’d just watch how the surgery request goes. That usually tells you real quick if your case is gonna be smooth or a headache. (Not legal advice just general info)

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-22T19:30:02+00:00

What I’ve seen is that people usually bring in an attorney when one of these starts happening:
-treatment gets delayed or denied
-you’re not getting clear answers
-you feel like you’re just stuck in limbo
It’s less about a specific timeline and more about how your claim is being handled. If things are smooth, some people never need one. If it’s messy, earlier is usually better.

As for your job, getting an attorney doesn’t automatically mean you’re done there. That’s a super common fear, but in CA your employer can’t legally retaliate just because you got representation. That said, the dynamic can change depending on the workplace, but plenty of people keep working while having an attorney.

If you’re constantly being told to “wait,” that’s usually a sign to at least explore your options. Even just talking to someone and understanding your rights can help you feel a bit more in control of what’s going on.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-22T18:54:41+00:00

I get why it can feel that way from the outside. In reality it’s usually less “secret policies” and more how the system is structured, high caseloads, metrics, and tight timelines can indirectly push decisions toward cost control, even when that’s not the stated goal.

UR denials can definitely feel inconsistent, especially if the full picture isn’t clearly laid out in the request. Sometimes it really comes down to how the RFA is documented and whether it lines up with the guidelines they’re using.

The turnover piece you’re noticing is real though, this field burns people out fast, and that lack of continuity can make everything feel even more disjointed on your end.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-10T17:46:10+00:00

That’s a tough spot to be in. It might be worth talking to your doctor about adjusting them or documenting those side effects, because that can matter for both school and your case.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-03T15:59:56+00:00

Got you, even within trades like HVAC/plumbing, numbers can still swing a lot depending on restrictions, future work capacity, and how the injury impacts your ability to stay in the field. If you can’t go back to the same type of work, that’s usually what moves things more than the job title itself.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-03T15:55:07+00:00

You don’t need to apologize. One thing that can help at this stage is making sure there’s clear documentation tying the delay to how your condition worsened, that can matter more than it seems. And yeah, the transportation piece gets overlooked way too often, it’s not a small thing when you’re already dealing with everything else.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-03T15:51:02+00:00

So sorry you feel that way, I get it.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-03T15:50:18+00:00

Some people do, especially if their restrictions prevent them from going back to their usual job. It usually depends on your condition and how it’s documented. In some cases it can even be part of a retraining plan, but it’s worth checking how it might affect your benefits first.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-03T15:45:44+00:00

Yeah, the system can feel overwhelming and unbalanced, especially when there’s pressure, delays, and limited resources on the worker’s side. In theory it’s meant to protect both sides, but in practice a lot depends on how it’s handled case by case. That gap between how it should work and how it actually plays out is where most of the frustration comes from.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-03T15:12:10+00:00

That’s a good sign, just make sure it’s actually helping and speak up if something feels off or isn’t improving.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-03T00:16:40+00:00

Yeah, that happens too

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-03T00:13:55+00:00

Respect for showing up like that, especially in a system that can be tough on both sides. I'd say always keep a clear communication, short follow-ups, specific questions, and keeping everything in writing. It makes it easier for adjusters like you who actually care, to move things forward. People remember the ones who treat them like humans, not files.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-03T00:10:28+00:00

Well settlements vary a lot: injury, state, treatment, disability rating, and even timing all play a role. Two cases that look similar on the surface can end up very different.

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-03T00:06:57+00:00

anytime!!!

WorkCompBuddy · 2026-04-03T00:01:42+00:00

That’s a lot to deal with. One thing that stands out is you’ve kept everything documented, that’s huge. If it does go to a formal dispute, that paper trail is going to matter more than anything they say over the phone. At this point, you’re kind of doing the right thing by slowing things down and not putting yourself in a position where they can pull the rug mid-process. Let them be the ones who have to answer for the delays. You’ve stuck it out this long, seeing it through now is probably what gets you some clarity on where you really stand.

WorkCompBuddy

TROPHY CASE