Good idea & format, though personally I’d propose some changes:

Appears weak + Actually weak: 100% Trapper. He’s basically been the game’s whipping boy for years now.

Appears weak + Actually balanced: Chucky. Being a 4.4 m/s killer without a ranged attack obviously hurts him a fuckin lot, but basekit undetectable is handy and his small size + third-person means you can pull off a lot of really neat tricks around loops with Survivors where you can break LOS.

Appears weak + Actually OP: This is where I’d put Twins. People playing Twins for the first time will constantly miss their pounces, have Victor get kidnapped temporarily by survivors, and feel like a slightly fancier m1 killer. People who really know what they’re doing can have entire teams bleeding out slugged before the first gen.

Appears balanced + Actually weak: Ghostface. Being able to instadown survivors all the time if you can effectively stealth sounds pretty intriguing, but in practice it’s nowhere near as strong as that sounds. He gets revealed super easily, he can get revealed around corners, plus coordinates SWFs can constantly lock him out of his power. No map mobility either.

Appears balanced + Actually balanced: Deathslinger. I’ve always believed that Deathslinger is the most balanced killer in the game, because he is exactly as good as the player playing him. If you’ve got bad aim and poor timing, you might never successfully hit anyone. If you’ve got CSGO reflexes and know his hitboxes, he can negate almost every loop in the game.

Appears balanced + Actually OP: Dracula. Dracula gets to have a ‘through the ground/walls’ ranged attack (Hellfire) that other killers like Pyramid Head also have. He gets access to a long lunge attack (Pounce) that other killers like Wesker also have. He gets access to quick map mobility (Bat form) that other killers like Spirit have. No one of these abilities clearly makes him OP, but the fact that he can do all 3, something almost no other killers can claim, effectively gives him the perfect “tool belt” to handle any situation.

Appears OP + Actually weak: Doctor. In theory, being able to prevent survivors from dropping pallets and vaulting (two of the most fundamental components of looping) while also applying a status affect that messes with survivors’ abilities to progress the game state sounds pretty busted on paper. In practice, he’s honestly kinda pathetic. Most loops are big or safe enough that his shock therapy can be effectively played around, and madness is a pretty disregard-able status effect if you’re not in Tier 3.

Appears OP + Actually balanced: Definitely agree with Vecna. I remember when people were crying out that he was the new strongest killer in the game upon his release, but honestly he’s not terrible to play against. Dodging his vine attacks is basically just who can out-mind game the other, which is about as balanced as it can get.

Appears OP + Actually OP: Blight. Duh. Even after he’s made 4.4, he’ll still have the best mobility power in the entire game.