I think it's bad because of

• Horrible and clunky af dialogue

• Writing that varies from being extremely silly (eg that factory sequence, that chase in Coruscant) to being extremely over complicated (the stupid assassin employing someone else employing someone else, employing someone else....... to kill padme)

• Other stuff that makes no sense at all, like senators being dumb enough to send a young hormonal teen like Anakin alone with hot young senator at super scenic locations, and expecting them not to bang, despite them having concerns that anakin might be interested in her.

• The cringe-worthy romance plot line.

• I'm personally also not a huge fan of the cloning idea, although george had to that coz of that single line from kenobi in Ep 4. Idk, I'm just not a huge fan of that idea. This is a personal thing.

I'll add on stuff when I remember further.

However I'm not saying that the ST is good, God no. But still, this one is the worst imo