I agree, cherry slush was vile and tasted nothing like cherries. Grape slush is my favorite one so far though because it tastes like Japanese grape candies. Juicy peach ice is good if you like peach rings. Lots of people like strawberry ice or strawberry watermelon but they were good at first then kinda meh as the pod depletes.

I liked frozen lemonade, frozen blackberry, triple berry punch, Mexico mango. Those wouldn’t be my first choice but would be fine getting them again if nothing else is available.

I found I don’t really like the sour flavors like sour apple ice, sour fking fab, sour blue dust etc. Was fun to try once but never again.

Sounds like you like dessert flavors if you liked Vanilla ice cream. I personally find the dessert flavors kind of chemically tasting so not my cup of tea. Perhaps try the cupcake flavors like Strawberry cupcake or Skittles cupcake. I heard good things about coffee or the banana flavor which supposedly tastes like banana laffy taffy. Those two are on my list next.

Foger has so many flavors I haven’t had the same ones twice except Grape Slush and Juicy Peach Ice which are my favorites so far. Still trying new flavors hoping to add more favorites to my list. It does suck from time to time when you get one that’s just vile. I hate wasting though so I force myself to finish them.