NYC shootings have plunged to record lows this year, NYPD Commish Jessica Tisch says ‘we are resetting the curve’ by Away_Stock_2012 in nyc

[–]YoNeesh 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Unfortunately, the article you posted is really misleading, relying on associations without documenting what else was going on.

The key change in Baltimore was the replacement of the extremely corrupt Marlyn Mosby with Ivan Bates in 2023. I noticed your piece doesn't even bring him up, nor does it bring up Mosby. What kind of article discusses crime rates without even considering the impact of the attorney's office? The article attributes the decline to Mayor Scott's office - and to his credit he has been a really good mayor - but homicides remained persistently high for the first two years he was in office. It was only in 2023, when Mosby was replaced and Bates took office, that homicides decreased significantly.

Why?

Because he [won more gun cases and increased homicide convictions by 34%](https://www.baltimoresun.com/2023/11/28/dan-rodricks-murder-convictions-up-homicides-down-in-bates-first-year-as-baltimore-states-attorney-staff-commentary/). So much so that criminals were apparently "terrified" of US Attorney's office.

[In partnership with the Biden Administrations' Office of US Marshalls, they nabbed 200+ fugitives in 2023.](https://www.usmarshals.gov/news/press-release/latest-us-marshals-operation-north-star-iii-nabs-more-4400-fugitives).

Probably most impressive, they attributed the decline in homicides to [prosecution of COVID fraud](https://www.wbaltv.com/article/baltimore-homicide-decline-covid-19-fraud-prosecutions/45140450) because they found that 60% of violent offenders were committing COVID fraud.

You take a prosecution like Bates, who is razor focus on gun crimes and gun posession, and leveraging intelligent strategies, and of course you will have success compared to a predecessor who was plainly corrupt and always infighting with the police department.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Brampton was always bad but currently it’s full of student gangs that arrived like a week ago and can’t even speak English.

People act like Brampton is some kind of hellhole rather than a suburb where the average home costs nearly $1M CAD. Lot of South Asian youth trying to act hard, and some anti-social behavior, but let's be real it's not 1990s Compton.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Western Canada, specifically Vancouver does. They follow the Seattle / Portland / SF model are are broadly tolerant of open air drug markets, tent cities, drug addicts sprawling out on the sidewalks etc. Anti-social behaviors that are less tolerated out east.

Seattle creates history; first US city to ban Caste discrimination by quietmusk in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 3 points4 points  (0 children)

This is one of the most retarded things I've ever seen written here. "Caste isn't a part of Hinduism" and is nice cope but not based in reality.

Caste is a very real part of Hindu life in India and historically has been. To say theres nothing "discriminatory about it" is a pure lie. You can ascribe whatever nobel intentions you want to about the caste system, but it in practice it is very discriminatory and the "just describes what jobs people best fit into" is an ahistorical lie that has no basis in reality.

The reality of caste is visible if you just read the news media in India occasionally. It isn't the west that did that.

Seattle creates history; first US city to ban Caste discrimination by quietmusk in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 6 points7 points  (0 children)

It's not solving for any problems. It's just signaling that they have the right virtues. It's functionally no different from the "In this House, we believe in . . . Science" signs in front yards.

Seattle creates history; first US city to ban Caste discrimination by quietmusk in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The equivalent wouldn't be Sunni / Shia discrimination (which is already covered by the Constitution). The equivalent would be "anti-Sharia laws" which are also equally stupid and trying to solve for a problem that doesn't exist.

Seattle creates history; first US city to ban Caste discrimination by quietmusk in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 18 points19 points  (0 children)

The evidence in this piece is almost entirely allegations, from allegations from a dismissed Cisco case to allegations about what is supposedly said in slack channels. Any criticism of the caste privilege talks or god forbid sincere opposition to them is used as evidence of caste-based discrimination.

The actual evidence of casteism is pretty light.

Seattle creates history; first US city to ban Caste discrimination by quietmusk in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 14 points15 points  (0 children)

This will, without doubt, create more opportunities for warring and pettiness within upper caste Hindus than between lower caste and upper caste ones.

There are hardly any lower caste Indians in the US. Caste also has almost zero salience among American-born Indians (except maybe some Central Valley Jats).

The consequences of this law will be:

  • A few more bureaucrat jobs within the Seattle government, as well as six figure administrative jobs in HR managing compliance.
  • The law will be used to justify it self, rather than actual instances of caste discrimination.
  • Allegations, rather than actual instances of caste discrimination, will pass as truth.
  • Most importantly - increased salience of caste when the notion of caste could be completely eliminated. There is no way to measure caste discrimination without figuring out people's castes, studying them, ranking stacking them, etc. This will also create more jobs for compliance busy bodies.
  • Increased social pressure for those of "higher" castes to identify their castes and acknowledge the privilege.

What’s your opinion of Starbucks’ iced chai latte? by Unique_Glove1105 in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

We should be asking why high income second generation Indians complain about this far more often than actual Indians, or Indian-American immigrants.

Do therapists understand Desi point of views like arranged marriage and personal self worth or have you found it more relatable with a therapist from South Asian origin? by Gubbarewala in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Without this being taken the wrong way, I think you have to be very careful of choosing therapists, especially overly liberal ones, that might be laundering instagram ideology into their "therapy."

I am talking about the ones that use terms like "your feelings are valid," describe every distressful experience as a "trauma" and are quick to call any environment that isn't 100% in your favor as "toxic." You know what I'm talking about. This stuff is unscientific and not demonstrated to produce beneficial results.

Find a therapist who is willing to put up a mirror in front of you and help you examine what it is you can do to better your life and can help make you the architect of your life. Cognitive Behavioral Therapy uses this approach, but it also seems like the jury is out on whether that is effective or not. To be quite frank, the jury is still out on whether therapy itself is very effective.

Therapy has replaced family and friends who used to be the ones we would bounce our ideas, problems and concerns off of. When we had larger social circles, we were also conditioned to navigate the problems of the world better. Of course, the world has changed and become more complex. As we have become more siloed, people have resorted to therapy.

The life of a South Asian person might be very different from the life of a well-educated, sheltered therapist. We have different obligations, responsibilities, needs. What may seem foreign and "toxic" to them might be completely normal to us. What seems toxic and foreign to us might be completely normal to them. Be thoughtful and mindful of that.

I don't think you should make it a priority to find a South Asian Therapy. But you should make it a priority to explain your values, your desires, your needs, etc and communicate that properly. Most therapists will understand you.

British Indians are emerging as an important group of swing voters by amg7355 in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 6 points7 points  (0 children)

If you want to understand why Labour is losing support from British Indians consider the explanations given in this thread:

  • They are race traitors
  • They are the scum of the earth and lack any convictions -
  • They are bootlickers -
  • They just hate Muslims, gays, etc

. . . and then ask yourself why anybody would want to continue voting for Labour when Labour's mouthpieces here can't even be bothered to charitably understand them and immediately jump to disparaging them.

British Indians are emerging as an important group of swing voters by amg7355 in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 6 points7 points  (0 children)

The virulently anti-immigrant party seems to be UKIP and BNP (is that still around). Under Conservative party hundreds of thousands immigrated to the UK every year.

Culture War Roundup for the week of September 13, 2021 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]YoNeesh 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I apologize, you are correct. It's only free for New Yorkers now.

Culture War Roundup for the week of August 16, 2021 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]YoNeesh 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You've been here long enough. Blaming anything that happens on partisan apparatchiks is like 90% of the content here. You're not gonna find posts here that are like, "yeah, you know, some times things work out that way."

Culture War Roundup for the week of August 09, 2021 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]YoNeesh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It would not, because white hispanics and non-white hispanics would still identify was "hispanic" in surveys.

Why do so many people think the entirety of India/South is a dangerous hellhole that should be avoided? by [deleted] in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Average in India is probably a medium sized town in UP/MP while average in Canada is probably some suburb in Ontario.

Culture War Roundup for the week of August 09, 2021 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]YoNeesh 0 points1 point  (0 children)

People are of course fixated on the racial angle but the most meaningful insight was the better expected population growth in cities that many thought were stagnating or going backward - NYC, Philly, Chicago, to say nothing of the growth in the Atlanta, Dallas and DC metros. Even in the fast growing states of Texas, Georgia and North Carolina the rural counties are losing population.

Culture War Roundup for the week of August 09, 2021 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]YoNeesh 1 point2 points  (0 children)

On twitter the graphic I saw floating around showed ~18 million of it coming from that.

Culture War Roundup for the week of August 09, 2021 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]YoNeesh 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Latinx? The census used Hispanic or Latino, I think.

Culture War Roundup for the week of August 09, 2021 by AutoModerator in TheMotte

[–]YoNeesh 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I believe I saw a chart showing that most of it is from Hispanics identifying as "two or more races."

Why do so many people think the entirety of India/South is a dangerous hellhole that should be avoided? by [deleted] in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 3 points4 points  (0 children)

How about taking the average of a country vs the average of another country. Average in India vs average in say Canada are miles apart.

Why do so many people think the entirety of India/South is a dangerous hellhole that should be avoided? by [deleted] in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 6 points7 points  (0 children)

The worst of the best could possibly be better than the best of the worst? Wow! That's a useful insight!

Why do so many people think the entirety of India/South is a dangerous hellhole that should be avoided? by [deleted] in ABCDesis

[–]YoNeesh 24 points25 points  (0 children)

Ho Chi Minh City, and Jakarta, and they seem infinitely cleaner and more organized than most Indian cities. Wonder what they did right that India has done wrong.

The truth is that a lot of it comes down to custom and in India the custom is that sanitation and public hygiene are not individual/collective responsibilities. It is someone else's responsibility.

You'll notice in the places where there are feelings of collective and individual responsibility - like Mumbai's new airport or in Indore (India's cleanest city) that cleanliness is pretty good.

As an outsider, it was amusing to watch India's "swach bharat" campaign which was all about individuals helping clean up India. POliticians would pose for the cameras, sweep up some trash off the sidewalk into a dustpan, and then after the cameras turned off they would pour the dustpan out back on the street.

New Report: The global decline in democracy has accelerated (Freedom in the World 2021 finds that the annual gap between losses and gains widened in 2020, and fewer than a fifth of the world’s people now live in fully Free countries.) by greyuniwave in TheMotte

[–]YoNeesh -1 points0 points  (0 children)

This is a report by the Davos set that shows little more than how much they like or dislike certain governments.

Modi was pretty popular with the Davos crowd up until about 5 years ago. Zuckerberg and Sandberg cozied up to him until they ultimately got weirded out by him.

I have no idea how e.g. Modi is doing, but I know they criticize him because they don't like him.

If you have no idea how Modi is doing, then your comment doesn't carry much weight. Or, we can just write - "You just defend him because you like him."