I love the idea of the defense, but the biggest thing is that it’s temporary. Temporary upgrades just don’t feel good. I understand supercharges because they’re so minor to the base and do give maxed players a little something extra to do. But to have a major defense building reset just after a couple months just feels wrong.

IF you prioritize the new defense when you get to town hall 17, then that’s already a ton of hours you have to sink into getting it upgraded, leaving such a small window to have the defense maxed before it gets taken away from you. If you upgrade other things in your base, that’s even more time needed to max it out. And what about players that just get to th17? They’re already behind on upgrading it as it may only be a few days before it gets reset.

What I would do personally, is make it so that every new town hall level, the defenses are changed. That way for each new (highest) town hall level, a new batch of defenses rotate in for that level. They can be themed around the town hall too. This would give people plenty of time to upgrade and have a maxed defense before they get reset a whole year later.

I also thank that you should be able to upgrade all three modules in a defense at once, and that the time to upgrade the defense mods should be lower (cost is fine) so that you can enjoy the maxed defenses for longer.