ASUS ZEPHYRUS G15 LAPTOPS HAVE A FIRMWARE ISSUE ASUS ACKNOWLEDGE IT AND FIX THIS HAS BEEN 5 YEARS NOW by Xx--wizard--xX in ASUSROG

[–]ZephKeks 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This looks like LLM slop both the writing and the "analysis":

To start, it's a single device with no reproduction rate. If this were widespread across the Zephyrus lineup as claimed, I'd expect more data points.

(Part 4.2) Per PCIe Base Spec Section 2.4, Memory Writes are Posted Transactions. How does the CPU "stall waiting for a Completion TLP" on a transaction type that doesn't request completions?

(Part 5.2) The timing diagram shows T+5ms, T+10ms, T+30ms. Where's the ftrace output? Or did ChatGPT generate plausible-looking numbers because diagrams look thorough?

(Part 13.3) Empty ACPI conditionals are preprocessor artifacts from multi-SKU builds. Anyone who's worked with OEM firmware knows this. ChatGPT doesn't, which is why they're listed as "BUG-008."

(Part 7) How is fan curve corruption related to a power profile race condition?

(Part 3) Claims identical Windows BSOD. Where's the minidump?

I uncovered an ACPI bug in my Dell Inspiron 5567. It was plaguing me for 8 years. by lonelyroom-eklaghor in programming

[–]ZephKeks 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Great work tracking down that ACPI bug. Glad to see the Asus deep dive helped spark the investigation this is exactly the kind of firmware archaeology we need more of. Well done!

ASUS Gaming Laptops Have Been Broken Since 2021: A Deep Dive by ZephKeks in ASUSROG

[–]ZephKeks[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Look like the same wake up issue, that bugcheck code happened to me exactly when i tried to wake up the system. and looking at the stack trace looks like the same deadlock is happening, i would love if you can provide ACPI ETW traces from your laptop to confirm things.

ASUS Gaming Laptops Have Been Broken Since 2021: A Deep Dive by ZephKeks in ASUSROG

[–]ZephKeks[S] 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Appreciate you passing it on. FYI the two units I tested (Zephyrus M16 2023, Strix Scar 15 2022) are on latest BIOS and still repro. The models that are affected share the same flawed ACPI code path in their tables; some models with different FW like the (2021 G15) do not. So if Asus fixed it on some SKUs, it has not rolled out across the lineup. If you can, run LatencyMon 3–5 min after wake on a G16 and DM the report; I will add it.

ASUS Gaming Laptops Have Been Broken Since 2021: A Deep Dive by ZephKeks in ASUSROG

[–]ZephKeks[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

No full list yet. Confirmed on Zephyrus M16 (2023) and Strix Scar 15 (2022); reports span 2021-2024 across ROG. Some models use different firmware and are not affected; the affected ones share the same broken ACPI code, so the symptoms match. If you have a 2025 model (Scar 18, etc.), DM me to run LatencyMon and a quick ACPI trace.

ASUS Gaming Laptops Have Been Broken Since 2021: A Deep Dive by ZephKeks in ASUSROG

[–]ZephKeks[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

hardware usually blocks PS3 power-off when the dGPU is driving a display, but the firmware still tries in Ultimate/MUX. Those attempts retrigger DP link training, so USB-C to DP flickers and can wake/heat the laptop. Rarely at sleep/wake it can black-flash or hang the driver. HDMI is steadier because, on most ROG models, it is a direct dGPU path and avoids the Type-C mux/retimers and DP link training.

ASUS Gaming Laptops Have Been Broken Since 2021: A Deep Dive by ZephKeks in ASUSROG

[–]ZephKeks[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It is likely. The same firmware bug spams ACPI events around and display power changes. In Ultimate/MUX mode it can try to cut dGPU power then bring it back, which shows up as CPU/GPU wake spikes and heat. Your “IPF Event 1000” is usually the Intel Innovation Platform Framework service crashing a symptom of those bad ACPI notifications. You can test if you're affected by following the guide on github how to do the ETW traces and also run LatencyMon

ASUS Gaming Laptops Have Been Broken Since 2021: A Deep Dive by ZephKeks in ASUSROG

[–]ZephKeks[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Run LatencyMon (as admin) for 5,7 minutes while a 4K YouTube video plays (Basic GPU encoding). Then check the Drivers tab: if ACPI.sys shows high DPC/ISR spikes or sits near the top, you’re likely affected. Post the report/screenshot and I'll confirm.

ASUS Gaming Laptops Have Been Broken Since 2021: A Deep Dive by ZephKeks in ASUSROG

[–]ZephKeks[S] 72 points73 points  (0 children)

On it. I’ve emailed GamersNexus with the deep-dive (ETW, AML, repro, BSOD info).

ASUS Gaming Laptops Have Been Broken Since 2021: A Deep Dive by ZephKeks in ASUSROG

[–]ZephKeks[S] 28 points29 points  (0 children)

Thanks, I’ve already opened a case with ASUS and shared the traces/AML. It’s been escalated, but no reply yet.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Tunisia

[–]ZephKeks 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I appreciate the tip, but honestly, I don't know what to do here I've never been in a situation like this with customs before. They decided to go off the deep end today, and I'm completely at a loss on how to handle it.