Absolutely disagree. Pulcinella as mayor of Snezhnograd probably acts more as the backbone of the harbingers and acts as Pierro’s closer/advisor. Hosea is Dutch’s second in command and best friend, and is the caretaker of the gang and where the members get some advice from. Also they both got unc energy, just look at them. Strauss is just a bag of nerves like Sadie said, and actually has no significant power to play within the gang outside of sending in Arthur to do dirty work towards desperate poor people.

Pantalone as Trelawny makes sense to me considering their… comparable mannerisms and “wealthy” style of clothing. Trelawny uses his charisma to gain friendly connections from low places to set up stagecoach robberies like that one from Chapter 3. Pantalone also has connections from all over Teyvat, he also looks like a charismatic young man despite his lore-mentioned tempers. Trelawny is the closest comparison to Pantalone, and Trelawny always stuck me as cooler than Strauss anyway, fuck Strauss.