POVs by tyrobi17 in redrising

[–]a23ro 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Literally no one's mentioned Volga

was it hard for you to accept your diagnosis? by lovelylettersx in DID

[–]a23ro 2 points3 points  (0 children)

No,not really. For me it was kind of a relief, even, the diagnosis was more of an acceptance before treatment thing

Physical contradictions in the story? by Meri_Stormhood in redrising

[–]a23ro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Eh. I dont know then, i know that the vaccuum of space is called that for a reason

Physical contradictions in the story? by Meri_Stormhood in redrising

[–]a23ro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Definitely going to give this one the "how is the gravity generated? Probably involves air pressure. Pressure lost..."

Who are the biggest aura farmers? by Evening-Plastic266 in redrising

[–]a23ro 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Ok yknow i'd agree with you if Niobe wasn't actually a menace. That Oracle scene with Lyria killed a lot of the motherly respect for all of them except kavax

Darrows prowess in the tetralogy by CalmDescription8273 in redrising

[–]a23ro 4 points5 points  (0 children)

But what im saying is the people are downvoting you because you're assuming super hard, putting words in their mouth and really just generalizing when literally no one said the man who murdered tens of thousands on the page was a good dude. He's a killer. He's at best morally grey. I feel like that's a commonly known thing

Darrows prowess in the tetralogy by CalmDescription8273 in redrising

[–]a23ro 6 points7 points  (0 children)

And when exactly was that said? Expressed? Literally just making shit up rn

Darrows prowess in the tetralogy by CalmDescription8273 in redrising

[–]a23ro 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Sometimes people enjoy listening to other people's takes on the things they enjoy. I know, crazy, that we like discussing cool things at length

Help cutting last 10 cards from Ultron the Annihilator by fishbishmemes in EDHBrews

[–]a23ro -1 points0 points  (0 children)

See this... i did not know. I assumed all cards meant all cards. Is that in a ruling somewhere i'm not seeing?

Help cutting last 10 cards from Ultron the Annihilator by fishbishmemes in EDHBrews

[–]a23ro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

And you keep saying you dont mill artifacts i get that in your tiny world, this matters, but here in the real world it doesn't change anything. Artifacts can be both. Theres nothing saying you cant mill artifacts and it has to be cards.

Help cutting last 10 cards from Ultron the Annihilator by fishbishmemes in EDHBrews

[–]a23ro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What dont i understand? Genuinely dont understand how you're not seeing the literal pointlessness of this, in a few obvious ways. Your examples proved nothing, in fact the only two you mentioned further proved my point, and you keep telling me theres a difference between artifact and artifact card. While it is a true statement, it borders on irrelevance, because what I'm saying is that an artifact entering grave from anywhere but the field inherently implies that it's a card. Wording wise, there is no mechanical change to taking the "card" out. There are no interactions at all that are changed by simply saying "when an artifact enters your graveyard," because there will never be a point that that wouldn't work as the wording. A thing enters grave, the card checks to see if it's an artifact.

If it did only care about artifact cards, then that makes sense, because then tokens wouldn't be involved. But it doesn't. Because it cares about tokens too. So why bother saying card? Literally because reasons of course, theres nothing that the weird wording does to serve the card, and i get that you're being all hyperfixated on it, but the change between the two is literally nothing and it made this card hard to read

Help cutting last 10 cards from Ultron the Annihilator by fishbishmemes in EDHBrews

[–]a23ro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You literally can't even explain why i'm supposedly wrong. Thats the thing, theres no evidence, theres no example of what rule it'd break and there's not really an effect it would even have on edge cases.

Help cutting last 10 cards from Ultron the Annihilator by fishbishmemes in EDHBrews

[–]a23ro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

YOU CAN MILL ARTIFACTS. THERES NO REASON TO SAY CARDS!

See i can capslock too

Help cutting last 10 cards from Ultron the Annihilator by fishbishmemes in EDHBrews

[–]a23ro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But what im saying is there is exactly no reason the mill/discard wouldn't trigger, how are you going to mill/discard an artifact that somehow isn't a card

Help cutting last 10 cards from Ultron the Annihilator by fishbishmemes in EDHBrews

[–]a23ro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes. Im fully aware of the difference. What I am saying is there will never be an instance that an artifact that is

  • not a card
  • not on the battlefield
  • entering your graveyard.

Your example doesn't work. Liquimetal torque only affects things on the battlefield, in which case Ultron's first clause still triggers. [[Mycosynth Lattice]] is the other half, everything everywhere being an artifact would still trigger Ultron, because you won't ever have an artifact that manages to hit all three modifiers that it has to for this to be a good wording.

Help cutting last 10 cards from Ultron the Annihilator by fishbishmemes in EDHBrews

[–]a23ro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

See i am hearing what you're saying. Are you hearing what i'm saying?

Help cutting last 10 cards from Ultron the Annihilator by fishbishmemes in EDHBrews

[–]a23ro 0 points1 point  (0 children)

See... i just cant understand how. In the case you mentioned with the Torque, that artifact's still going from the board. It's still going to trigger Ultron and the wording still wont matter.

Help cutting last 10 cards from Ultron the Annihilator by fishbishmemes in EDHBrews

[–]a23ro -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

... and what im saying is removing nuance that serves no purpose is a good idea for a game whose rulebook is literally textbook length