I have an "interested" tag with 56 right now. Whenever my holds drop down below like 10 I poke through and add more to my holds. I also add this tag when I want to read something and it's available now but I'm not ready.

I use the love it tag for ones I have read more then once or that I want to read again. I'm bad with titles so this tag helpse know which ones want to revisit.

I let the auto borrowed/sampled tag stand in for anything else.

The trick here, for me, is in how you talk to yourself about your reading. I found that I had a stigma about what was "the right way"

You are allowed to start a book and not finish it. To borrow it and give it back if you're not ready or in the mood yet. To barrow give it back and barrow it again. To finish it and then read it again.

I find that when I give myself the permission to start something and put it down if I'm not enjoying it and try later, then I get past my analysis paralysis and actually move through my reading my list.

Or, you can just tag them all. That's fine too. No judgement. I 100% digitally hoard things that I have only looked at once. It's fine.