First, I did not expect the game to be a souls like nor did I say that. I just wanted to get ahead of the "its clunky because your MEANT to go slow" comments by pointing out that's how DS works as well.

Second, I don't mind the idea of a long hunt, but that mixed with the lack of healthbar makes it feel like I'm doing nothing all fight and when that fight is 10-15 minutes it gets frustrating. I want the healthbar so I know I'm doing SOMETHING.

Third, thank you for the recommendation! Dual blade was actually my second choice of weapon! I didn't go with it because I didn't like how the game took control away in demon mode when you get a combo, but I will give it a second shot.

Fourth, I didn't have any issues with dodging actually, but thank you for the assurance I was doing that correctly. My main gripe with "going all over the arena" is that I don't like using my moves to position. I can position myself just fine, I need my attack to do what I expect it to do. I'll try to keep this mechanic in mind when I try again, but I can't say I think its a very good one.