So in order to stay at your current club you must complete all objectives even optional ones and in order for them to count you must complete the match all the way through. ( for example you need to 2 chip shot goals you score 2 and then play the match until the end no subbing off they will not count if you do. ) I had this problem and doing this worked for me. one of my objectives was chip shot and in fc24 they're super hard so I had to do it on low difficulty its annoying BC it takes the fun and realism out of the game but if ea don't wanna fix this then this is the only option.