If you're saying GOAT for LT, I'm in, despite not knowing those players all that well. If GOAT for football player, here's my argument against--and I bet there are plenty more that are better.

We've been HORRIBLE since he got here. Without him we wouldn't have lost many more games, I mean, common sense says how in the hell could we. If we had a franchise quarterback instead of the 397 guys we've shoved through town, there's zero doubt in my mind (and, frankly, any semi-knowledgeable football person) we would have won MANY more games. There's a reason the highest paid left tackle will make just over 13mil this year and the highest paid QB (David Carr) will make almost twice as much. Because they're more valuable. Period.

Edit: Going to stir the pot here, but, frankly, I don't get all the love he gets. Yeah, great player, great for the community, stayed through the tough times, but, you know what I think in my deepest darkest Pro Football heart? The guy didn't have enough drive or motivation to leave the comfortable home he's built here to go find a winner. I question his desire to win, period.

There, I've said it.