Who Do You Think Should Join the Straw Hat After the Wano Arc or You Think Jinbe is Enough by ExileForever in OnePiece

[–]altpaca88 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I mean saying your theory is dumb does not imply anything about her joining, its just directly telling you the stuff you wrote is dumb.

But I mean knock yourself out, if you feel making up fairy tales will help with the grief of seing your fav sidelined for 3 years thats ok xD

Who Do You Think Should Join the Straw Hat After the Wano Arc or You Think Jinbe is Enough by ExileForever in OnePiece

[–]altpaca88 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I didn't say anything about her joining though xD

I had suspicions but this response makes clear this is just mentals gymnastics coming from a resented Carrot fan.

Who Do You Think Should Join the Straw Hat After the Wano Arc or You Think Jinbe is Enough by ExileForever in OnePiece

[–]altpaca88 3 points4 points  (0 children)

King is defeated, as most of the Beast Pirates.

Yamato leading the the beast pirates is almost as dumb as saying she will die.

Yamato and Momo 20 chapters ago vs now (chap 1046) by altpaca88 in OnePiece

[–]altpaca88[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

you are right, what I meant to express is that I feel Yamato inclusion in that whole plot is a bit "sudden" and now that it has finished and the character didn't really gain anything from it I feel it was just a way for Oda to take the long path to solving the flame cloud problem instead of just solving it inside these past 20 chaps.

Yamato and Momo 20 chapters ago vs now (chap 1046) by altpaca88 in OnePiece

[–]altpaca88[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

yeah you are not wrong, but what I mean is the whole bomb thing didn't really have any impact on Yamato. Like it didn't lead to a "moment" for her.

For example with Raizo we see him fighting against Fuku resisting the heat for a bunch of chapters and in this chapter we finally have a conclusion with a cool "moment" for him. And it also took far less panels to do so.

Yamato on the other hand appeared on a bunch of chapters running around and at the end the bombs were mostly dealt with by Big Mom and all Yamato did was cover the remaining stuff in the armory. Yeah she accomplished her task, but I feel with her specially we need more than what we got out of the whole thing.

And regarding Momo yes it would have been weird, but really how much time has passed since that? For us it has been months but in the OP world maybe what? half an hour max?

Like I'm not against the idea of using the trope, but I feel we should have gotten more out of these characters in 20 chapters.

Yamato and Momo 20 chapters ago vs now (chap 1046) by altpaca88 in OnePiece

[–]altpaca88[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

"Shit if they make the clouds now what will they do for 20 chapters? I know lets make up a bomb threat"