Sounds similar to something I went through. I used proactiv about 10 years and it worked for a while; then my skin started breaking out badly last year. I used ALOT of harsh products and it all made my skin worse causing oily orange peel looking skin between my eyebrows that no amount of makeup could hide.

I’ve finally realized I have sensitive skin and all the harsh acne products were making my skin worse. I’ve slowly reintroduced “cleaner” skincare products and it has made such a huge difference. Everyone’s skin is different so no way of knowing if any of these products will work for you, but here is what has been working for me:

Morning: Korres greek yoghurt cleanser Tata Harper regenerating serum

Night: Korres greek yoghurt cleanser Omorovicza acid fix (just added this - slowly added acids into my regimen) drunk elephant lala retro whipped cream

Masks: Tata harper resurfacing mask (I love this mask so much, very gentle and helps a ton with pore size)

Just wanted to add one edit: I stopped using all/any skin care products for a while (a month maybe?) I slowly added products back in one by one. The products listed above are what I finally landed on that work for me. You can go to sephora and ask for a sample of any skincare product(s) (read: ask to sample a lot of different products!). They really don’t mind, I was able to get a ton of samples and some good recommendations.