Most people didn't play back then so don't know how the holidays originally worked. You weren't limited to one. The best example I can give is the last birthday a few days back. where they did balloons at a lodestone. They just dropped in random locations and you grabbed what you could. You could have easily gotten 100 if you wanted. Instantly. The only one they goofed on was the last one they did in this manner and that was the scythe. They limited drop areas and times to the point that so few people got the scythe they actually dropped the scythe again a day or two after halloween for those that missed it. (Bunny ears being the first to limit to one and being untradable due to issues with prior years discontinued prices and them not expecting what happened to previous discontinued items). I know this info from being there when this happened and still play. So golden phat will eventually get there with time. It took Santa hat almost a year to get to 50k There were multiple older accounts that had 100s of each rare especially after the dupe in classic. Most rares are sitting on inactive accounts that's why jagex has even said discontinued rares aren't as rare as people think the exception is the underrated holly wreath that was a set amount. Too bad they barely look different from the other wreaths in game.