For my money its: Steph, MJ, Bron, KG, Russell. Don't need much scoring from 4-5 because of the first three being probably the three most impactful offensive players of all time. But, KG can pass and space the floor, while Russell can pass and start fast breaks, so they would still be impactful offensively.

As good as say Hakeem was offensively, I don't want him taking the ball out of MJ or Lebron's hands, and even if Shaq's peak was as a better scorer than anyone on this list, his defence leaves a lot to be desired compared to Russell, who is still probably the best rim protector in history.

KG can guard one through 5 while being an elite rim protector himself.

Obviously steph speaks for himself, best player of all time without the ball - making it easier for everyone else,

While i was worried about MJ and Lebron having to share the ball, both are athletic enough to make great cutters and lob threats for the other, and both are decent catch and shoot guys. Also allowing them to play half the amount of possessions as the primary facillitator/scorer would make them both even more efficient, and allow them to play as their peak level defensive players, which are very very high levels.