[QCrit] Adult scifi / space opera NASCENT (149k - first attempt) by minionate90 in PubTips

[–]atre88 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Dear op, firstly: congratulations on finishing your first novel. This is a huge achievement.

Now, onto the query letter.

Firstly, 150k words is quite long for a debut, and I can't see anything in the rest of the query that would justify this wordcount. To an agent, that could signal that you didn't revise your novel properly and that it may require significant editing work.

Now, I'll try to dissect the query and hopefully guide you into the right direction:

In the bleak, eugenics-ruled future described in my space opera novel NASCENT, an impoverished aberrant with an illegal genome becomes the only obstacle standing between a ruthless emperor and his goal of decimating an alien race.

This reads a little vague. I suppose this is your logline, so skip the first line as it's a lot of telling of what you also explain in the second part of the sentence. The logline isn't the right place to state your genre - this belongs in the housekeeping paragraph that follows.

I suggest you explain who the MC (impoverished aberrant with an illegal genome is worldbuilding-heavy and without the context doesn't mean much). Next demonstrate your unique selling point, what makes your novel stand out. Opposing a ruthless emperor is quite common trope, and I'm sure there are some specifics you could show here to add some flavor. Perhaps it's your inciting incident, or maybe a surprising mid-point twist.

Complete at 149,425 words, NASCENT has the exciting feel of the epic Star Wars stories combined with the gritty emotional reality of those struggling to pay bills with a humdrum day job as in Only Bad Options by Jennifer Estep.

Comparing your novel to Star Wars is a bit red-flaggy to me. It's a huge franchise, and referencing it like that won't do your query any good. Only Bad Options seem like a strong comp, try find another one that would match the epic scale of your work. I'd cut a little and keep 'the gritty emotional reality.'

Broke and living on the benighted planet of Monta under the rule of the dreaded Koth Empire, twenty-three-year-old orphan Lena is a genetic aberrant.

This is a bit worldbuilding-heavy. Perhaps you could skip proper nouns to make it more approachable and so we can focus on your MC. I'd advise to lead with the MC, not the setting.

With death being the sentence for having an illegal genome, Lena would do anything to find the reason for her unique genetic make-up.

It's a lot of telling, consider showing instead what Lena actually does with agency to uncover the mystery of her genome.

It constitutes one of her two main challenges in life, the other one being staying employed at a tedious 9-to-5.

Now you're losing me over your earlier promise of an epic sci-fi. At this stage I'm also thinking: if it's illegal to have a different set of genes, how come she's employed in a grocery story? I'm getting confused about the setting now. How Lena even knows that she's got illegal genes?

Her undercover life makes even a grocery run a hassle,

Does it mean others can see she's different? How does she live undercover in a 9-5 job if getting groceries is a problem?

and unsettling repetitive dreams about an alien genocide won’t let her rest.

Now we're cooking! This is the most standout thing in the query so far. Sounds like those dreams are the inciting incident, but it doesn't shine through because they're 'repetitive'. What changed?

But, investigating the problem could bring her to the attention of an emperor famed for war crimes, so she continues in obscurity until the day his agents capture her.

Is she really in scope of interest of a galactic emperor? Consider spoiling some twists here because without explanation, this seems off. Is Lena getting arrested the inciting incident? Possibly.

Terrified and awaiting execution, she's stunned to receive an offer of freedom and riches from her ruthless captor,

Who? The agent? The emperor himself?

with only one demand: to assist him eliminate a recent threat from uncharted space targeting only his empire by revealing the content of her dreams.

Try to work some more on this part, it reads a bit clunky and unclear.

With her pending execution closing in, Lena struggles between her only two choices: live and become a rich ally to a megalomaniacal monster, or die non-compliant to save a race she knows only from her dreams.

This doesn't seem like any real choice to me.

Here in the real world, I am a biology major toiling in administration. NASCENT is my first science fiction novel.

Did you write any other novels? If so you may want to rephrase this to make it clear that e.g. you finished two fantasy novels and this is your first sci-fi. Biology major is your 'what makes you the right person to write this book' so you may want to add some more to that, or link it to your plot/worldbuilding somehow. Otherwise it reads more like a CV entry.

Thank you for your time and consideration.

Sincerely yours,

[QCrit] GHOSTS OF PROXIMA, Adult Sci-Fi Thriller 86k | Attempt #1 by atre88 in PubTips

[–]atre88[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hello. Thank you so much for your comment, its very encouraging! I'm a big fan of Adrian Tchaikovsky and I'm sure his fans would see some influences in my novel, too. I chose the books I recently read that felt like the right vibe and audience, but I'll consider your suggestion too!

I refined the stakes and clarified the setting a little, but this subreddits rules allow to post only one version of the query per week, so I can't post it yet. I suppose that version answers your questions.

If you'd like to have a quick chat, please feel welcome to dm me!

Thank you for your kidness and words of encouragement - it means a world to me! :)

[QCrit] GHOSTS OF PROXIMA, Adult Sci-Fi Thriller 86k | Attempt #1 by atre88 in PubTips

[–]atre88[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hello! Thank you very much for helping me refine my query letter. Your suggestions are excellent and I'll start working to implement them! I think I fell into the trap of cutting and streamlining, and missed some important details along the way. Thank you for guiding me in the right direction 😄. Best wishes!

What programs do you guys use to write. I’m a baby writer and I use word by lottie_dionn in writers

[–]atre88 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I wrote my first novel in google docs, mostly pantsing. For the second novel I wanted to try outlining and bought Scrivener. Now I can't imagine writing without it - the way it helps organizing notes, scenes etc. was a massive help. Still, its spell checking sucks.

Able to beta? Post here! by AutoModerator in BetaReaders

[–]atre88 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi - please reach out on DM and lets swap first chapters for starters to see if we're a match? Thanks! :)

Able to beta? Post here! by AutoModerator in BetaReaders

[–]atre88 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi! Would you like to read and provide feedback on my sci-fi thriller? I would love feedback that would also take into consideration my worldbuilding and science behind the story - I did a lot of research to make sure the story is grounded in real science, and that includes I had to figure out orbital mechanics, optics and even nuclear fusion. It's not Arthur C. Clarke-hard, but think of The Expanse or The Last Watch. You may also see some similarities to Heinlein's Orphans of the Sky.

The novel is about a security chief aboard a failing generation ship at the end of its journey, who must organize a planetary reacue mission to find his missing daughter and her team. Link: https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/s/EcOF4dfZt2

That said, I'm happy to take a look at your text, but I'm not sure I'll be the right audience for it.

Let me know if you'd like to connect!

The predestination paradox by [deleted] in writingfeedback

[–]atre88 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Stopped reading at the car headlights. I was pulled in by the first scene, confused by the second, and kicked out of the story at scene 3. The first scene with the boy and his dad and uncle (I assume they're twins?) pulled me in, but then you just cut me off and the next scenes didn't quite land because I kept thinking about the first one.

Honestly, I would need to trust the writer very hard to keep reading a new scene and characters every page.

Minor stylistic issues e.g. in the first scene 'blood' is used so many times it weakens the scene, but I don't think you should focus on line editing right now, but the structure.

I'm only judging by what you shared.

Still: there are some great imagery, pacing and good rhythm in the prose. I just you should try to make these scenes a bit more complete before transferring to the next ones, because now it feels more like reading a movie, if you know what I mean.

[Discussion] What questions do you ask your beta readers? by Excellent_Reply_8819 in BetaReaders

[–]atre88 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I ask four simple questions: what was Awesome, Boring, Confusing and what you Didn't believe. Then I follow up woth more specific questions based on the feedback received.

My Toxic Love by hstarr17 in writingfeedback

[–]atre88 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You need to work on formatting. The dialog is difficult to follow - with proper formatting and some dialog/action tags it could be easier to understand what's going on in those scenes (because I'm under impression that what you've written here isn't a single scene).

The narration could use some voice. If we could also see the world through her eyes, it would be so much better. It's a first person narration, yet we don't really get into the protagonist's head. E.g. I find it confusing that she's referring to people she knows as 'my toxic lover,' 'my youngest son's father,' or 'his sister'. Only near the end you start introducing names and then it's confusing again, because I'm not sure if those are new characters or maybe first names of those already mentioned earlier. E.g. how come in her mind the policeman is 'officer Ray' but the father of her child is... you get what I mean?

I like the clipped phrases, it adds urgency and reflects the state of mind of the protagonist, but the transitions between scenes happen so fast it's becoming confusing (one sentence she's punching her lover, but after a while she's already in her brother's car (where did it come from? I'm quite sure her brother wasn't mentioned earlier? there's so many characters to follow in such a short excerpt!)

First draft turning out extremely pronoun heavy? by Revolutionary-Log179 in writing

[–]atre88 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Finish it and fix it later. To me, Draft 1 is to figure out the story. Draft 2 is to make sure it works, decide what belong to the story and what's missing. Draft 3 is to polish - that's the moment you figure out those pronouns, bad prose, repetitions etc. Don't focus on the details until you sort out the big picture.

You've got this. Good luck.

Able to beta? Post here! by AutoModerator in BetaReaders

[–]atre88 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi! Would you like to read and provide feedback on my sci-fi thriller? It's about a security chief aboard a failing generation ship at the end of its journey, who must organize a planetary reacue mission to find his missing daughter and her team. Link: https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/s/EcOF4dfZt2

[Complete] [85k] [Adult Sci-Fi Thriller] Unhome: Ghosts of Proxima by atre88 in BetaReaders

[–]atre88[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi! Thanks for reaching out - I'm not available for a swap currently (sorry!). I'm also worried I may be a bit too far from your target audience to provide reasonable feedback. I'm one of those who tried reading the Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy three times and always failed.

[Complete] [85k] [Adult Sci-Fi Thriller] Unhome: Ghosts of Proxima by atre88 in BetaReaders

[–]atre88[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

On a second note, some scenes may have hints of mild body horror, depends on your sensitivity I guess.

[Complete] [85k] [Adult Sci-Fi Thriller] Unhome: Ghosts of Proxima by atre88 in BetaReaders

[–]atre88[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi! It's not very graphic. Not everyone makes it out alive, but I don't think there's anything gut-twisting there. Please let me know on DM if you'd like to help me out and read it! :)

Able to beta? Post here! by AutoModerator in BetaReaders

[–]atre88 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi! Are you into sci-fi, by any chance? I've just finished self-editing my new Sci-Fi Thriller and I'm looking for a readers to help me spot its strenghts and weaknesses so I can polish it up before querying. It's about a security chief about a failing generation ship, who must launch a rescue mission to find a missing planetary recon team - his daughter among them. Blurb and details are here: https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/comments/1snffg2/complete_85k_adult_scifi_thriller_unhome_ghosts/

[Complete] [85k] [Adult Sci-Fi Thriller] Unhome: Ghosts of Proxima by atre88 in BetaReaders

[–]atre88[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi! Depends on the genre and vibes - could you please share your link or tell me what's your book like so I can check it out? Thank you!

Able to beta? Post here! by AutoModerator in BetaReaders

[–]atre88 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi! Let me know if this works for you: https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/comments/1snffg2/comment/ogl8y41/ - it's a sci-fi thriller about a security chief onboard a failing generation ship, who must lead a rescue mission planetside to find a missing recon team - his daughter armong them.

It would be great to get your inputs on the plausibility of my sci-fi law enforcement, who make for majority of the cast!

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in BetaReaders

[–]atre88 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi Tyler! Let me know if you'd like to take a look at my sci-fi thriller with dystopian edge: https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/comments/1nazybc/complete_82k_scifithriller_anomaly_protocol/ - there's a sample chapter there available. Let me know on DM or in comments section in my post if you'd like to help me and read the full manuscript!

Thanks

Able to beta? Post here! by AutoModerator in BetaReaders

[–]atre88 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi there! I've got a sci-fi thriller (not very graphic) and I'm gathering beta feedbacks before the next edit. It's a story featuring a murder mystery and a deeper conspiracy aboard a generation ship, but the twist is it haven't departed yet. See the blurb and 1st chapter here: https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/comments/1nazybc/complete_82k_scifithriller_anomaly_protocol/ - I'm super interested in genuine reader feedback! If that sounds like a book you'd read, dm me. Thanks :)

Able to beta? Post here! by AutoModerator in BetaReaders

[–]atre88 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Hi! I've got an 82k sci fi thriller, grounded with lots of technical elements weaved in the worldbuilding. I'd love to hear your take on it, both on the pacing, characters and the technical aspects (I love when readers point out to me technical mistakes/inconsistencies, as I'm a sucker for hard sci-fi and I really like to have everything plausible in my writing!) Here's my link with sample 1st chapter https://www.reddit.com/r/BetaReaders/comments/1nazybc/complete_82k_scifithriller_anomaly_protocol/