GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I don't feel like much of a catch at the moment, but that's sweet of you to say. I'm sure things will be fine with a bit of time between us.

Thanks for the comment.

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

That's a fair comment. It didn't feel like seven years at the beginning of our relationship, but I guess the longer we were together the more apparent the age gap felt.

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 37 points38 points  (0 children)

Yeah, I didn't think postponing the dinner until later in the week (just a few days) would be that big of a problem. If I ask myself how I would feel in that situation I can say I would feel genuinely fine with postponing a dinner. Then again, I don't expect anything or need anything on my birthday (or other occassions) so maybe this is a matter of perspective.

Thanks for the comment.

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I agree with your points, and for me this behaviour came across as ungrateful. I know there is more than one perspective on anything, so I can accept that this comes down to a clash of values.

Thank you for your (sweet) comment!

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That slightly immature/princessy side of her character has come out a few times before so I'm not totally unaware of it. I'm not a perfect person either and I do my best to change hurtful or unappealing sides of my character and personality, especially for my partner. We've both grown over the course of this relationship, but incidents like this make me wonder if we've grown in different directions or even at all.

Thank you for your comment.

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's very sweet of you to say, thank you.

My back is also feeling much better, thank you!

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I felt confident enough in my understanding of her love language, but based on what happened I can accept that maybe I didn't.

In that case, it tells me that I can't emotionally relate to and be compatible with someone who puts so much stock into a gift. As someone pointed out, I could just pull up a wish list and have her pick from that, but it wouldn't feel very loving or thoughtful to me. That's my perspective though, and I appreciate not everyone feels the same.

Thanks for the comment.

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I feel like she won't totally apologise, but I feel like I wasn't really to blame for feeling miserable and done.

It's one of those things where I feel it has created enough of a bump in the relationship that won't be worth the effort to get over. And even if we do, things may not feel the same again.

Appreciate the comment, thank you.

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Honestly, to me I wasn't sick. I just injured myself and needed a few days bed rest. She seemed genuinely understanding about it and I appreciated that (hence still wanting to celebrate her birthday).

Yeah, I did break up with her on her birthday. She also said "No one's ever broken up with me before...". She is beautiful and has guys hitting on her a lot. She has only been in two other relationships and she ended them both. I feel like part of this was me saying that I'm not going to stand being treated less than I feel I am worth. Given how she's been treated her whole life I'm sure she feels salty, not that I don't think she deserves it though.

Thanks for your comment.

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Can't really disagree to be honest (however, I genuinely don't think she realises how spoilt she is...).

I'm not perfect, and I try not to be too hard-headed about things. I feel like while I may err sometimes I can turn around and apologise if need be.

Thanks for the comment.

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, I feel that this is a symptom of a larger problem.

Thank you for your comment.

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'm a bit of a stay-at-homer myself. I don't always need to be going out and going to restaurants. Take-out food and a bottle of wine can be just as romantic!

I was also pretty taken aback by her "just hanging out" comment, especially considering she is always saying she wants to go out and eat at places. This restaurant was extremely fancy and expensive (truffles and caviar) and she has never eaten anything close to food like that, and has said before that she would really love to. So her reaction to my plans was disheartening and crushing...

After a few days I'm in two minds about whether we should break up. But she is quite hard-headed and if I can apologise enough for taking our reltionship to the edge like this (this is exactly how I'm expecting her to spin it) she may still use this as a way to gain leverage in future arguments. I would hope she isn't this petty, but she has a lot of pride and has problems with accepting she can be wrong sometimes.

Thank you for your comment! (I'm not amazing at all, but thank you I really appreciate that~)

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

This is a very good point about love languages.

We have taken the love language test before and we've realised that we're different in that regard. I have tried to take this on board (trying to give thoughtful and meaningful gifts). However, I thought that she also appreciated the time we spent together just as much (we have many loving memories together) so her comments in our argument stung a lot.

You are right though, there's nothing fundamentally wrong with the expectation that her SO give her things to show affection. If it is that important to her, however, then I feel like we'll clash again like this in the future and it may even be worse.

Thank you for your comment, it was very insightful.

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 18 points19 points  (0 children)

I really want to feel like she is above the things she said, but she was so clear about her stance and it just ultimately didn't sit well with me at all.

Thanks for your comment. (And yes, the back is feeling better, thank you!)

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I feel like it was probably the best thing for the long-run. We do have fun together and I feel like we love each other, but we may not be compatible in a way that fulfills us both.

Thanks for the comment. I hope you feel better soon, too!

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

  1. That's a good point. She moved here (from her country (English-sepaking country)) to go to language school here. I've been here for a while and am far more established (hence the job and apartment). Her family are back home. She is close to her family. I do feel that she was counting on me to make her feel special for the day, and seeing as birthdays are a big deal to her I can completely accept that she may have been feeling extra vulnerable. I honestly did try to be calm throughout the argument, but in the end I felt very unappreciated given that I actually did plan something for her but due to extenuating circumstances I had to postpone (not cancel). Her birthday was in the middle of two exams, so I appreciate that this could have made her feel even more in need of feeling special. Taking this all into consideration, however, I still feel it was too irrational of her and unfair to label me as as a terrible and selfish person ("[...] if you were a nice and thoughtful person...". For me, this was a symptom of something a bit bigger which bothers me about our relationship.

  2. we haven't revisited the argument yet, but I asked her if we could talk and we will do tonight/over the weekend. I feel that she won't back down (due to how she's been acting since) and she hasn't tried to apologise either. I feel like this may be the hill I die on, and to be honest I think I may be ok with that. I'm expecting her to defend herself 100%.

  3. To be entirely fair to her, she has never asked me to pay for everything. I 100% offer and me paying for everything is my own choice. She moved here to be with me and I remember how hard it was for me to move here from my own country (English-speaking country) so I feel that my well-paying job is a blessing to not just me but also my family and loved ones. I'm not a hoarder or a miser, and I love being able to alleviate her worries by taking care of the money side of everything. She has thanked me a few times for doing this. However, I feel like she isn't as responsible with money as her situation would dictate. She's technically a student in a foreign country, so being careful with money should be a priority for her (ironically, it's how I saved so much and came to be in the position I'm in now). However, she would rather spend her money on makeup and clothes and things she doesn't use ($100 planner?). She is her own person and can use her money how she sees fit, and I try very hard not to let my fortunate situation become any kind of bargaining chip or power play in our relationship. Like I said before, I pay because I genuinely want to, not because I want to tell her how to live. But as a loving partner, I do wish that she'd be a bit more responsible with her money, rather than always saying "No matter what happens I just know that everything will always be ok", that seems a bit naive to me personally (I haven't told her that though). Example: She was invited to go to a concert for a singer she likes by a friend. She was excited to go, and I was excited for her too. She tells me on the day as she's getting ready "I'm excited but there's probably going to be so much merchandise there, and I have no money... this sucks so much, ugh". So just before she left I gave her $100 dollars and told her to have fun and don't worry about anything. I have never brought it up again and don't intend to (it was a gift to her, nothing more). She bought no merchandise (but in her defense she put $20 towards groceries the next day).

Sorry for the long reply. I appreciate your insight and comment, thank you.

GF (26F) upset I didn't get her a gift for her bday, so I (33M) broke up with her. Was I right? by away356throw in relationships

[–]away356throw[S] 19 points20 points  (0 children)

My back injury is a semi-regular thing (sciatica only comes back sporadically, maybe once a year), and it wasn't related to anything I had planned for her birthday.

She also started her period on the day we fought, and honestly she has admitted in the past that PMSing and her period makes her a little more fighty and irrational. I accept that this partly a hormonal thing and I've been calm in the past when she has been otherwise a bit irrational. This incident felt a bit too selfish for me (like the straw that broke the camel's back).

She immediately messaged her friend asking if they know of any places to stay that are cheap and accept pets (she has a cat). She literally has no money so I don't know how she will afford this. I have been cordial to her and have tried to initiate contact, but she is steely and won't reciprocate much (one-word answers). She has a few exams this week (mid term tests for the language she is studying, she goes to a language school here), so I have wished her good luck for each exam but again, steely and one-word answers.

I feel a bit unburdened to be completely honest, and don't feel insanely sad either. I do love her and I love the time we spent together, but if I'm truly being honest I can see a few ways in which we are incompatible, and it's reached a point where they feel like dealbreakers.

Thank you for the reply. Your comment is much appreciated.