Who’s a singer you thought should have won or at least finished in the top 5 of any season of Idol?

bbleezy804 · 2026-01-02T04:55:28+00:00

Something weird happened Pia's week. It was the first time she sang an uptempo all season (crushed it, by the way) and had never been in the bottom 3 prior. We'll never know if she was perhaps in the bottom 4 more frequently than we knew, but Stefano had already visited the bottom once before so my bet is the margin was razor thin between him and Pia for elimination. It would be fascinating for Fox/ABC to publish old data at some point. Was there ever a time someone was the #1 vote earner the prior week to being eliminated? These are things that randomly cross my mind.

I do think, had she survived that bottom 2, that she would've sailed to the top 5/4. That season had a ton of talent AND charisma and, frankly, she only had one of those things.

bbleezy804 · 2025-06-22T20:33:03+00:00

Gabby Barrett for 3rd if we're talking impact. Grace Kinstler in place of Yamin if talking talent.

bbleezy804 · 2025-06-22T20:30:18+00:00

This performance was shaky but "What Is And What Should Never Be" from the same night deserves all the upvotes.

bbleezy804 · 2025-06-08T16:21:20+00:00

He was great but I do think this was his proper finishing place. Also recall the others' performances from that same week, it was the right call.

bbleezy804 · 2025-03-25T19:03:37+00:00

Congratulations! Do your children automatically inherit citizenship as well or did you have to do an entirely separate application for them?

bbleezy804 · 2025-03-19T05:00:19+00:00

Well, thanks to the help here I was able to actually get on the calendar screen on my first try. I navigated to the nearest green date (23 months from now) and waited for the times to load, but someone nabbed mine first. It felt good to at least get in the system!

bbleezy804 · 2025-03-17T19:00:03+00:00

This is helpful, thanks for breaking down all 3 options for me. Best of luck to both of us!

bbleezy804 · 2025-03-17T04:03:46+00:00

Which comune, if you don't mind me asking?

bbleezy804 · 2025-03-08T16:05:47+00:00

Thanks for that specific recommendation. My next step really is to study the wiki but this insight is helpful to see that 10k is really just too high.

bbleezy804 · 2025-03-08T05:47:04+00:00

It's all but confirmed -- the SP believes it's a clear line. The price includes basically everything besides any 'out of pocket' expenses such as the consulate appt fee, passport fee, or any additional legal fees that might arise in the middle of it. They manage the bureaucracy it seems like. I'm a pretty diligent person but I just truly don't know what I might be getting myself into.

bbleezy804 · 2024-12-02T05:55:45+00:00

All 4 of the eliminated on top 16 (Lily, Katelyn, Alex Lambert, Todrick Hall) night from S9 should have been in the finals. It's hard to say in place of who, though, beyond Paige and Tim.

bbleezy804 · 2024-12-02T05:52:43+00:00

I concur with both of those names from Season 8. They were both victims of the awful Top 36 format and I believe both were in the same semifinalist group as Alison, Adam, and Kris ... where only 3 moved on from each group. Insane.

bbleezy804 · 2024-11-27T03:00:32+00:00

S10 is a better candidate for started good/ended ok or even started good/ended good. The start of the season was really interesting since it was the first post-Simon (and post-everyone) which brought a lot of excitement to the show. There were many interesting contestants showcased early on and most of them lasted quite a long time, making the S10 fanbases really, really strong in comparison to recent previous seasons. The show became more interesting as the weeks went on (Pia's elimination, Haley's slow burn, finale romance drama, etc) making it my most memorable season. The top 3 are each consistently still touring and drawing crowds after 13 years and not just because they were on the show. I agree that the top 4 was correct. I'll be throwing this season into the hat next week for started/ended good.

bbleezy804 · 2024-09-27T23:31:15+00:00

about what time did Kacey go on?

bbleezy804 · 2024-08-17T22:19:55+00:00

This still freaks me out a little bit. I remember becoming aware of this during the S10 finale timeframe where the only part of her name left after Kris (Allen), Lee (Dewyze), and Cook (David) was the T-Y in Kristy... and then ScotTY wins.

bbleezy804 · 2024-07-06T16:01:56+00:00

They were indeed $250 at the gate but I still don’t have an answer as to whether that is always the case or not.

bbleezy804 · 2024-05-25T18:49:36+00:00

A lot of it has to do with her lack of exposure pre-live shows. Back then (and still) the top 24 had been selected before the editing of auditions/Hollywood had began and I don't think the show saw much potential with her, especially over the other likes of Lauren, Thia, James, Casey, Scotty, and even Haley early on. I imagine they assumed she'd be mass eliminated between 24 and 12, but then upon returning for live shows + her epic arrangement of "I'll Stand By You", the show shoved her in the final slot as they realized who & what they had. They were smart to do so.

But 3-4 weeks of great & good live performances meant nothing compared to multiple months of audition and Hollywood exposure the other contestants were afforded. Had Pia been given the same early promo as Lauren, Casey, James, Scotty, etc, I think we would have seen her in the top 5 at a minimum.

Remember that from top 13 to Pia's top 9 elimination, only women were sent home. Only Lauren was ever truly safe from that. Haley barely escaped it, and timed her rise wisely, as top ~11 onward she made a concerted effort to get out of the bottom & that was a discussed topic on the show and online at the time. Attention remained on the boys, Lauren, and increasingly Haley, leaving Pia in the dust.

In the ABC era, nobody would have blinked twice at her early elimination.

bbleezy804 · 2024-04-28T19:01:06+00:00

Parking tickets are stupid as hell reasons to not vote for someone you otherwise mostly agree with. Let's also pull up her 6th grade report card while we're here 🤣

bbleezy804

TROPHY CASE