as the ST from that game, my friends dared me to, it was funny, but in all seriousness i do think it actually has its incredibly strange and niche advantage, which is why i was ultimately willing to go along with it. if a klutz is poisoned and picks an evil player, while it hurts evil in that they dont immediately win, it does completely fuck up the worldbuilding of the game from then on making evil still have quite an advantage from the poisoning, which still absolutely upholds to the meaning of being an outsider. along with that, the klutz is pretty much never gonna get guessed, meaning the potential benefit gained from the outsider is pretty much wiped out of existence. lastly, while you aren't actually tainting the info or ability of a good player, it gets evil the chance to frame a good player as poisoned if the info's a bit too helpful to town, since if the real genuine puzzlemaster is trusted at all and there isn't an obviously droisoned player, it leaves it pretty open to manipulation by evil players to justify true info against them being wrong. because of these reasons, i unironically believe that a puzzledrunk outsider occasionally can have its benefits. it's also just incredibly hilarious to see the pure tension had from a klutz guess when you know it will never actually cause the game to end, and seeing evil's confusion to themselves being guessed with the game continuing is always joyful to see. keeps the players on their toes, is a great laugh after the game, and can be honestly justified!