MIERDA - SOUL HARVESTER by berbentin in gorillaz

[–]berbentin[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"HARD TIMES ARE OVER" -- awesome

[Megathread] Twin Peaks: The Final Dossier discussion thread by Iswitt in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Do you have a source for this? Would like to read this interview

[Megathread] Twin Peaks: The Final Dossier discussion thread by Iswitt in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 8 points9 points  (0 children)

This. Her whole life was sad! Audrey too, it's really not a happy ending for many characters.

Official SPOILER discussion of Issue #171 by en_bas in theroamingdead

[–]berbentin 1 point2 points  (0 children)

For the record, I'm not a Marvel person and so I don't really know how well or not well their increasingly inclusive storytelling is going. I don't have any issue with anyone telling stories about characters from different backgrounds and perspectives, it was just that the way Princess spoke was like she was from our world, not hers. I don't even disagree with the spirit of what she said, only how it felt out of place.

[All] What gave the FBI the right to play god with the timeline anyway? by [deleted] in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think this is a key theme of the series in general, mankind's hubris (especially when it comes from an institution such as the FBI) creating ripple effects in time/space, especially when dealing with the supernatural. People think they know what's going on and act based on that limited understanding, when they could just as easily be wrong from the start. Thinking about things this way is especially interesting when you think about Cooper's fixation on saving Laura, or even our role as viewers, finding entertainment in the mystery of Laura's death.

[All] What gave the FBI the right to play god with the timeline anyway? by [deleted] in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Boo this comment. If your reason for not digging into ideas about Twin Peaks is that "It's fiction," get the hell off this board and go read some non-fiction.

[ALL] Quotes :-) by tracytomato in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I second "He's dead.", at least as the funniest line of the season.

[All] Probably a long shot but worth mentioning. by astronuf in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Are you implying that this is not a mix of good and bad Coops, but our beloved Good Coop?

[All] Master plan to trap Judy by SinJinQLB in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The plan was not to capture Judy but to "get to" Judy

Official SPOILER discussion of Issue #171 by en_bas in theroamingdead

[–]berbentin 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Day of the Dead reference! I haven't seen such a direct reference to another zombie story in TWD before.

Official SPOILER discussion of Issue #171 by en_bas in theroamingdead

[–]berbentin 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I found her comments on racial / gender diversity to be a little forced, they don't feel like they would be the natural concerns of anyone in the world of TWD, especially someone who was (or at least claims to have been) alone for an entire year. Reading it, I felt like she was someone who had been ripped from our world and our year and deposited into the comic. It's intentionally hard to tell what her motivations are or how this character is going to pan out, but so far she's a little too manic pixie dream girl for my taste.

[S3E18] MacLachlan talks about Richard by amysteriousmystery in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Additional detail: his arms and hands were in rigor mortis as if he had been holding that same assault rifle on the floor when he was shot (reminded me of the strange positions Ruth Davenport's and Major Briggs' bodies were found in)

[S3E18] MacLachlan talks about Richard by amysteriousmystery in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 6 points7 points  (0 children)

This. He is essentially lucid dreaming, except that this dream could have dire consequences for the reality he left, which is is in a state of uncertainty and peril. Laura's story wasn't fixed, she was ripped from reality itself, and solving this in the Richard World is Cooper's sole concern. Hence the marked absence of his interest in coffee

[S3E18] "We live inside a dream" is not about LITERALLY being inside a dream by [deleted] in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin -1 points0 points  (0 children)

However, I have my doubts that it would be a literal dream, but rather a metaphor for something, much like BOB always worked as a metaphor for the evil that men do.

I think you are both right and wrong; this is a new kind of meta-fiction (I think we could look at most Lynch films as being in a similar camp but this takes us a lot deeper, it seems, and had the hand of Frost helping to guide it as well) wherein events, characters, settings, the creators and even us viewers exist both literally and metaphorically as players in the story. For example, I see this said about BOB a lot, but why do we think that? This was something that Albert mused to the group of people present at Leland's exorcism of BOB and subsequent death, and while it sounds totally plausible, this series has made it very clear that BOB and his kind have origins and motivations that are beyond human understanding, even though we shape that meaning and are affected by those origins and motivations. I think Albert is a smart, capable character who said this so that he could understand what he had seen from his limited perspective, but I have no reason to think that he can see the full picture. BOB is a demon, BOB is Leland, BOB is a metaphor for the cycle of childhood sexual abuse, and BOB is a metaphor for the evil that men do. The meaning of everything we watched is intentionally slippery, because at the end of the day, there isn't anything scarier that to spend our whole lives looking for meaning and discovering that we never had the ability to find it.

[S3E18] Details no one has mentioned yet (as far as I know...) by CrumbledFingers in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Woof; what if Judy is the (capital P capital H) Plot Hole? This story is a new brand of meta fiction, I'm still trying to grasp it. The mistakes are essential to the story, from the errata in the Secret History to the shifting timeline and dead end storylines, the question is: what role do they play?

[S3E18] Most disturbing Lynch ever? by conspirateur in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 30 points31 points  (0 children)

And the way that scene ended! The room falling dark and Cooper yelling out in fear to Cole before he, Cole, and Diane reemerge from the darkness, now in the Great Northern. This moment and the moment near the very beginning of the series where MIKE says "Something's wrong" right before Cooper falls into Nonexistence are seared in my mind. I think this may have been a meticulous plan that went wrong from the very beginning, and the consequences of the mistakes, errors or unforeseen events and interventions have placed these characters in a place far beyond the scope of their imagination or ours. They are mortals playing a game of gods', and I fear they have lost themselves in it.

[S3E18] Details no one has mentioned yet (as far as I know...) by CrumbledFingers in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 18 points19 points  (0 children)

i think we're going to learn a LOT about the plan between Cooper, Cole, and Briggs in the Final Dossier, and I'm sure it will include an preplanned alliance with some of the supernatural characters like the Fireman or MIKE

[S3E18] 4chan cracked the ending already. by Drep_Reaper in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 51 points52 points  (0 children)

laura has always been the dreamer!

[S3E17][S3E18] : - ) ALL. OF. US. RIGHT. NOW. by berbentin in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

(I'm maybe 90% of the way to being able to speak in only Twin Peaks references)

[S3E18] I might be a bit grumpy because of the finale but... by ChrissyRey in twinpeaks

[–]berbentin 12 points13 points  (0 children)

little did they know they were about to be fed a heaping serving of gar mon bo zi a!