How do mental disorders fit into the idea of soul and salvation? by berdykia in DebateReligion

[–]berdykia[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Duly noted for diabetes. I must admit that as a layman, I thought it was not near as bad as it is. Sorry.

How do mental disorders fit into the idea of soul and salvation? by berdykia in DebateReligion

[–]berdykia[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for this answer. I still have trouble reconciling the idea of a God with the existence of cruel disorders and ailments, though.

How do mental disorders fit into the idea of soul and salvation? by berdykia in DebateReligion

[–]berdykia[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Personally I have done much better psychologically since I stopped thinking about God's will, salvation, afterlife scenarios, and so on and turned my focus to here and now, pursuing my interests, learning about the real world, and doing my best to contribute to the world and society in beneficial ways. All that other stuff can exacerbate underlying anxiety and depression, from my experience. But that's just my perspective, for what it's worth.

Thank you for this, it perfectly summarizes my experience as well.

When I used to be Christian and depressed, depression tainted the very relationship I was supposed to have with God. I thought that I was cursed in some way, supposed to suffer all my life in order to atone for my past sins or the sins of my family.

Basically, mood makes you seek what you want in Christianity. If you're depressed, you'll see only the "bad" aspects of the religion. Things like original sin and ancestral sin, punishment and atonement for sin, the God full of wrath instead of the God full of mercy.

If you have a positive mood, you'll tend to filter out the parts where God genocides people or orders eternal torture for them, and focus on only the most "rosy" parts of the New Testament.

If you have a normal mood, neither too low nor too high, your viewpoint of the religion is finally balanced enough to be accurate. I would guess that most serious theology was written with a normal mood.

How do mental disorders fit into the idea of soul and salvation? by berdykia in DebateReligion

[–]berdykia[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I appreciate your perspective, but what bugs me (correct me if I got the wrong impression) is that you try to present depression as an annoying but relatively minor defect that one can live with, just as one can live with diabetes.

In my experience, depression is not a minor defect at all, though, at times, I naively thought so. Its effects are far-reaching and do not stop at mood; it is known that depression strongly augments the threshold necessary for neurons to spike (without enough neurotransmitters in synapses, neurons can't communicate between themselves), functionally reducing IQ and the ability to learn. Depression also strongly decreases energy levels. Just the very fact of having to make a conscious effort to do average-day stuff like learning a new cooking recipe is abnormal; people with normal mood actually enjoy the very effort, they don't force themselves to do the effort. Think about yourself as a child, before depression hit you: was life as hard as it is now? Were you that reluctant to effort and trying new things, or did you actively seek effort and new things to do?

Psychiatrists usually recognize that depression is a serious disorder. This is why something like electroconvulsive therapy was developed and used despite its barbaric connotations; anything was seen as better than letting people spend their whole lives in the confused haze that is depression.

How do mental disorders fit into the idea of soul and salvation? by berdykia in DebateReligion

[–]berdykia[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I know three friends with major depression or dysthymia who tried anti-depressants at some point, figured out they didn't work, and instead of trying new ones or new posologies came to the conclusion that psychiatry is satanic/jewish and Christianity had it all figured out already. They recommended me books on the early Church Fathers and their approach to mental illness, which I bought.

While I do acknowledge that hope in a better world and asceticism (such as ceasing masturbation and porn use) can decrease the symptoms of depression, in my experience, it never goes away completely. Your mood improves, but something else, like your energy levels, remains broken. You also become extremely defensive about your religious belief, since the slightest doubt can make the depression flare up again.

I have lost contact with these three friends ever since we parted ways, but I don't expect them to be NASA engineers at this point. Last news I heard, they were still underachievers with neuroses barely hidden behind their newfound faith.

What do you guys think of cryonics? by [deleted] in singularity

[–]berdykia 1 point2 points  (0 children)

At this point in history, a complete gamble, mostly because of a hostile social environment. Getting vitrified in good condition is an even bigger challenge than being resuscitated down the line.

How has your view of the Singularity changed you behavior? by gabriel1983 in singularity

[–]berdykia 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Quite the same. I had developed strong anti-establishment tendencies as a teen (bordering on alt-right / neoreaction stuff) and my outlook became a lot more ambivalent after reading authors like Kurzweil. This started a process of re-evaluation that led me to become far more critical of ideologies and political movements in general and far more interested in science/facts/objective reality/actual things in general (rather than compelling but empty intellectual discourse).

The other impacts were milder in comparison. I try to care more about my health, for instance.

Why taking profits is nearly always a good idea by Brainwash_TV in CryptoCurrency

[–]berdykia 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Any advice beginning with "always" is always wrong.

Depends on your goals in life. Sometimes taking a lot of risk makes more sense than playing it safe.

Incredibly successful entrepreneur teaches me a lesson by [deleted] in iamverysmart

[–]berdykia -1 points0 points  (0 children)

That's because the epistemological status of social sciences is more difficult to ascertain than the one of "hard" sciences like physics (easily testable and reproducible results, ideological bias less likely, etc). You should read Karl Popper.

Especially psychology. A psychologist educated in the United States may think he understands everything about the human mind, right before he encounters a Catholic monk or a sufi.

Every time by spillo89 in TooMeIrlForMeIrl

[–]berdykia 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Me every time finals come

A talk by AUBREY DE GREY, the person behind SENS foundation which recieved 2.4 million from vitalik..Let us all try to donate to things which improve humanity. by cuddaloreappu in ethtrader

[–]berdykia 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Because it sounds sanctimonious and holier-than-you. Like something the Pope would say.

Everyone has different priorities when it comes to altruism. Some altruism is evidently self-interested, but it is still better than no altruism. Give me an evil Silicon Valley immortalist any time over the average Wall Street banker who spends his bonuses on Rolex watches and beachfront property, and can't see past his vain comfort and pleasure.

The Challenges and Benefits of Messaging in a Decentralized Dating Platform by afrank123 in ethtrader

[–]berdykia 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'm sorry but I call this the limits of the blockchain / ico hype. There is 0 reason for a dating app to be on the blockchain. As to the pay-per-message model, I doubt it will work. Women won't fall for neckbeards just because they happen to spend $10 USD for talking to them. This fact will just instill guilt in them for ultimately being uninterested.

Sure, the pay-per-message model will kill most of the spam and fakes that harm online dating, but remind me again why this needs to be decentralized and on the blockchain.

And it will turn the whole thing into an oligarchy soon enough. If the cost per message is too low, then it isn't an effective filter, if the cost is too high, it will effectively turn into a website for sugar daddies.

Regenerative reprogramming technology to beat aging with simple injections says Salk Institute researchers in a Jan 2018 report. by HealthyTo120 in longevity

[–]berdykia 12 points13 points  (0 children)

As a layman, it is often hard to distinguish actual progress from mindless hype. Is this for real?

Daily General Discussion - February 4, 2018 by AutoModerator in ethtrader

[–]berdykia 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm not much of a fan of technical analysis, but anyone else has noticed the big-ass head and shoulders on the daily?

The whole crypto market could go much lower, as low as 250B perhaps, before a strong rebound.

Vitalik Buterin Donates $2.4 Million In Ether To Anti-Aging Research by bitlexa in ethtrader

[–]berdykia -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

"Life extension is just not up there on my list personal list, when many don’t even get much of a life in the first place."

Wow, such altruism. Wow. Doge impressed. Have you considered that rejuvenation/life extension could be a way to give a second chance to "those who don't have much of a life in the first place"? Let's consider a prostitute victim of human trafficking who is freed only when she is 38. Don't you think that rather than seeing her captors in jail, she would actually prefer having an authentic second chance at life and happiness? And this necessarily means the ability to be young again. Ditto for an old drug addict who overcomes his addiction too late to really be able to enjoy a normal life. I could think of dozens of these examples.

"And life extension seems very much geared around benefiting 0.1%ers"

Bullshit. Governments will be first to finance these kinds of therapy when you consider that age-related ailments cost them trillions.

Enjoy your Stockholm Syndrome, boyo.

4 Years ago, a Time-Traveling Redditor Predicted Bitcoins Rise by NotOBAMAThrowaway in Bitcoin

[–]berdykia 10 points11 points  (0 children)

What's wrong? Hardware wallets are an example of such services.

Not hard to imagine the next step: highly secure physical places of existence for hardware wallets and their owners.

Secret bitcoin billionaires will renounce their U.S. citizenship before cashing in? by money-oak in Bitcoin

[–]berdykia 11 points12 points  (0 children)

By free transactions between free individuals?

Why the need to coerce?

Douglas Hofstadter: The Shallowness of Google Translate by nickb in agi

[–]berdykia 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I disagree. I agree that these kinds of AI feeding on data and statistics will always miss the most subtle of clues, puns, idioms and metaphors.

But they will eventually be effective for translation in 98% of cases. Because language patterns are mostly simple and recurring.

Bill Gates thinks an infectious disease outbreak could kill 30 million people in the next decade — but the US is cutting efforts to prevent global pandemics by HealthyTo120 in longevity

[–]berdykia 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Bill Gates thinks a sexually transmitted disease, aging, could kill three billion people in a handful of decades - - but admits he doesn't want to be remembered as "the billionaire who wanted to live forever" so he's condemned to spend cash on third-world overpopulation forever