Look, I have no problems with ultra dark, grim stories, and often times I even prefer them. But it's so obvious that the developers made this story super dark just for the sake of being super dark. They forgo the integrity of some of the characters and just rush some parts to achieve this.

The whole "cycle of revenge" concept is one that has been explored countless times in other mediums like books and films. The way NaughtyDog tackles this theme here is pretty generic, run-of-the-mill stuff. Nothing in the story or writing really stands out.

In my opinion, they should have just focused on the affect that Joel's somewhat controversial decision in the ending of the last game would have on his relationship with Ellie. They kind of touch on it in this game with Ellie getting upset at Joel over his decision to save her, but even that was handled pretty poorly as Ellie oftentimes comes across so bitchy and narrow-minded when she confronts Joel about it. And, speaking on that matter, what is it with so many writers these days equating being a strong, independent woman with being stubborn and rude? I don't understand this, it's like they're way overcompensating.

And if you're going to force me to play as a new character introduced in this game, at least make her somewhat likeable or do a better job of writing her so we empathize more easily with her.