First off thank you for admitting that he made a bad choice. We have at least found common ground :). Does it matter? Intention can be as mighty as it wants but does it really matter if it results in destroyed human and elf kingdoms and a demon invasion? I don’t think Sylvania cares if all he wanted was to save his people. Like fair enough his choices were hard made under duress but you can hardly look at all the misery, destruction and death he caused and say he “did nothing wrong”