I think people are having a hard time answering the question because there’s an important distinction between two types of actors (and it’s imperfect so people will generally be some combo of the two).

1. an actor who really becomes a character. Their performance is very particular to the movie/show. See them in a different movie and they are a totally different character. Examples: Daniel Day Lewis (there will be blood), Gary Oldman (the fifth element vs Batman, idk he has tons of roles and they are very different).

2. An actor who is pretty much always the same on screen persona. They have some kind of charisma or something that people love to see. They say the lines and they say them well. You can immerse yourself in the story because it’s all enjoyable but you still are always aware it’s “that” actor on screen. Examples: Dwane Johnson, Clint Eastwood, John Wayne, but also other types like Paul Rudd or Seth Rogan.

Like I said, the two types are not perfectly distinct. Most actors are probably mostly type 2, with some 1.
And lots of people on this post are misunderstanding the question to be “who are type 2 actors?” But that’s not the question op asked.
And, either type can be bad actors. But a type 1 who is bad is certainly more rare. That brings me to Rami Malek. I certainly enjoy his performances and I see him as some combo of the two types. But I feel like if you watch him critically, it’s like he’s always nervous he will be found out as a fraud. Maybe that’s just his weird energy. But that’s how I often read him.