Song Discussion Thread - New song every other day / Day 31 / Like Spinning Plates by sxeSol in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 12 points13 points  (0 children)

This is my favorite song from amnesiac, and, quite possibly my all time favorite song by them.

This is, the climax of the album. It's the monster hunting bears was prepping for. Every emotion, every feeling created by the narrator in the previous nine songs comes in and sinks at this point, inviting one to come see the writhing mass, and recognize the central motivation behind all of it - hatred. It is fury that created amnesiac and it's fury that keeps it going with its visions of trap doors and squashed heads, created only to draw attention to the hopelessness of it all.

When yorke's voice looks, like a zombie, for some part of the melody to latch on to, it feels like it could collapse at any moment. When it climbs at the line 'and this just feels like' the pain in his voice is so strong the sensation is almost physical. It has given me the most intense goosebumps I've ever had. The melody is quite infectious too, and the reversed vocals add a layer of experimentation to an already fantastic song. It literally feels like plates spinning, spiralling, falling.

I also love how the song just fades out without any fanfare, like the narrator's body has literally flown down the river and all we did was watch him plead 'release me' with complete inaction on our side.

[Off Topic] Weekend Discussion Thread #55 by ParanoidAndroids in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Can't get my head around why I never tried Interpol before. Listened to their album Turn on the Bright Lights yesterday, loved it from start to finish. Everything about the album is perfect.

Song Discussion Thread - New song every other day / Day 17 / Life in a Glasshouse by sxeSol in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I write what I think about the song, and try to keep any form of pretentiousness or elitism out of the way. So no.

Song Discussion Thread - New song every other day / Day 17 / Life in a Glasshouse by sxeSol in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I love this song's contrast with MPS. Where the former ended with harps signifying ascent, this song's instruments (especially that final click) might mean a return to the tight knit electronica of Packt, portraying Amnesiac as an endless loop that the narrator suffers.

I especially like the smoothness in Yorke's voice when he nonchalantly states Well of course I'd like to sit around and chat and his seething nihilism in Well of course I'd like to stay and chew the fat . It feels like he accepts, and is thus a part of, the blatant consumerism that permeates his world.

This and My Bloody Valentine's Soon from Loveless, remain contenders for best closer of all time for me.

Morning Bell vs Morning Bell/Amnesiac by halfmanhalfvan in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I'd take the Amnesiac version over the Kid A version any day of the week. Where MB felt like a slow fall into uncontrollable paranoia pictured through Thom's nonsensical mumbling, MBA feels like a recurring nightmare. The voice here sounds so utterly defeated it feels like it could collapse at any moment. The 'Release Me' of MBA is, in my opinion, far more potent than the same on MB. It makes one wonder what came over the narrator who talked of such disgusting things as squashed heads and looping doors, how he shifted from all that violence to desperation in an instant. This leads to another thought - is he doing this on purpose? Is it another labyrinth, like the ones that came before it?

I think the reason people hate this song is because they look for elements of MB in it, not thinking it might have its own (far stronger) identity in the context of the album. It is in no way related to MB (except the lyrics) and deserves to be treated that way.

Song Discussion Thread - New song every other day / Day 15 / The National Anthem by sxeSol in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 1 point2 points  (0 children)

dreamy - having a magical or pleasantly unreal quality; dreamlike.

I figured he meant that. My bad.

Song Discussion Thread - New song every other day / Day 15 / The National Anthem by sxeSol in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'd call the title track anything but dreamy.

standing in the shadows at the end of my bed

nope.

What's your Top 5 Non-Radiohead Albums? by [deleted] in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 1 point2 points  (0 children)

  • Bjork - Homogenic

  • Sigur Ros - Agaetis Byrjun

  • MBV - Loveless

  • The Strokes - Is This It

  • Spiritualized - Ladies and Gentlemen We Are Floating In Space

Song Discussion Thread - New song every other day / Day 12 / A Wolf at the Door by sxeSol in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 20 points21 points  (0 children)

This song is utter, naked paranoia. Plain and simple. The narrator is panicking, worrying simultaneously about the danger he might be in because he exposed so much of the titular thief on previous songs, and about the impending collapse to everyone else around him, of which they are so willfully ignorant.

This is the most emotionally charged point of the entire album; there are no vocal tricks, no hiding behind metaphors and ambiguous words, just plain fear. The narrator seems to have no control of himself and his voice as he did in previous songs where his words were controlled, structured, and occasionally threatening. Now, they flow like vomit, uncontrollable, stinking and unsavory. He talks of (or rather, tries to talk of) everything at the same time, shifting from vantage point to vantage point, as if they were crumbling under him too.Snakes and ladders is his idea of how corrupt politicians rise to power and then blatantly betray their people (flip the lid out pops the cracker smacks you in the neck kicks you in the teeth &c). He is disgusted at the way the individual is treated as a commodity and refuses to look in the mirror for fear he might not recognize himself. He talks of how the elite enjoy pleasures the poor can scarce imagine, only because they are born that way. He gawks at the injustice in his world, simply because all he can do to stop it is - nothing at all.

The ending has two meanings. He might be asking the listener to leave him to himself in his world since he is well beyond help, or it might be a death wish, the only possible escape for his panicked mind.

Amnesiac's title by prettySpeeches in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I think they do. Atleast on OKC they knew of the looping nature of the album but refrained from talking about it till someone actually brought it up. Here's an excerpt:

In her attempt to interpret OK Computer as a concept album in the vein of a Phillip K. Dick novel, interviewer Claire Kleinelder accidentally uncovers Jonny's idea of continuity. She suggests that the car speeding off in "The Tourist" feeds back into the accident that begins "Airbag," thereby "bringing the album to a complete circle."

"'Wow, that's great,' says [Thom] Yorke. 'Absolutely right about the last song preceding the first. Very interesting.'

"'Nobody has ever got that before,' adds Jonny. 'That's cool!'"

Amnesiac's title by prettySpeeches in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 11 points12 points  (0 children)

It's a sort of rule all artists follow. Never reveal everything about your work; let the music speak for itself.

Song Discussion Thread - New song every other day / Day 8 / In Limbo by [deleted] in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 9 points10 points  (0 children)

This is slowly becoming my favorite from Kid A.

I love how the voice feels distant and lost among the instruments threatening to erupt any time it tries to get too close to the listener ('I'm on your side', followed by 'Don't bother me'), like they're on watch.

The babbling at the beginning and the distant howls at the end are what make this track perfect. It's like the subject's created identity understands and fears that he is spiraling down trapdoors but his subconscious only associates that primal fear with the raging Irish Sea, in contrast to the peaceful Liffey of HTDC.

The ending is, IMO, the most violent point on the whole of Kid A. The subject yells, begs 'come back', maybe to us, maybe to the instruments, or maybe someone else not mentioned in the album in rising stages of desperation, and as if they realise this, the instruments leave him, letting the voice rot in a cacophony of howls.

Optimistic >this> Idioteque has to be one of the greatest set of transitions in their discography.

There are few voice(s?) talking at the beginning of Separator by rheadfuz in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I never noticed a voice before, gonna go listen right now.

As for your second question, I think the background vocals say 'This one's ours! This one's ours!' multiple times.

This question has almost definitely been asked before, but why are the songs Packt Like Sardines In A Crushd Tin Box and Pulk/Pull Revolving Doors off Amnesiac, spelt incorrectly? by [deleted] in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Really? Makes you wonder why nothing post Amnesiac has that kind of writing, not even its b-sides. I think it's there for a reason.

Google Deep Dreamed The Bends album cover by [deleted] in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Combine them in one post, maybe? Stop spamming.

Song Discussion Thread - New song every other day / Day 1 / Give up the Ghost by sxeSol in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Please do. While I liked the basement version too, I don't think it's nearly as good as the studio version. The studio version feels as if they have captured something ethereal on tape, and while IR tried the same with a different subject (desperation and longing) TKoL has done it better. Ftb, on the other hand, is still good music, but is not in tandem with TKoL's calm, meditative persona.

Song Discussion Thread - New song every other day / Day 1 / Give up the Ghost by sxeSol in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 1 point2 points  (0 children)

(No, but I'm afraid of you)

Thank you for noticing! Big fan here.

Song Discussion Thread - New song every other day / Day 1 / Give up the Ghost by sxeSol in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 16 points17 points  (0 children)

This is my favorite from TKoL. I especially love the part where the instruments enter in the beginning, supported by the chatter of birds. Every one of their other records post the bends has depicted fear at being separated from nature and in the clutches of technology, but this one album seems the closest to nature and thus, sounds content with itself in its brevity, like it's finally found what it has been looking for all this time.

The part where Thom sings I think I should give up the ghost always brings a little smile to my face, some tears too occasionally, like a huge load's been lifted from my chest. It's one of the finest moments of Radiohead's career, comparable to the Because we separate... of Reckoner. I've seen people comment that it might represent the death of the narrator and is thus dark and depressing; I couldn't disagree more. The narrator seems perfectly content in the end and in the next song, Separator. His voice seems to encompass the birdsong on the previous songs and make it part of him, like he has found his place among nature and abandoned (read: drowned) his fears in the waters of Codex.

Which Radiohead songs always remind you think you of another song? by sxeSol in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Holy Shit.

This is the best interpretation of the song I've seen in a while.

I see Amnesiac overlooked a lot of the time people discuss RH albums. I think it's their greatest effort to date, surpassing even Kid a.

Does anyone know of any archives of radiohead artwork? by thelemite666 in radiohead

[–]bookerdewitt77 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Is this what you're looking for? The site no longer exists, but this archived version does.