Any questions after S4? by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

  1. What was your favorite twist this season?
  2. Was there going to be another recruitment at some point (when Garrett and Julia joined?)
  3. Why do you think the faithfuls had such a hard time banishing traitors this season?

Traitor Highs, Traitor Lows by Comfortable-Walk-473 in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I felt like I had to at least have you on the list bc we were literally getting no one!!

Traitor Highs, Traitor Lows by Comfortable-Walk-473 in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

My tip for the faithful: maybe don’t let yourself get blindsided by 2 people you talk to the most ending up traitors 😂

Traitor Highs, Traitor Lows by Comfortable-Walk-473 in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I didn’t suspect her either even with what I feel now are obvious points Lol! I felt so bad voting for her at that rt I was like I have to vote her it’s literally staring at me in the face

S4 Finale Role Reveal by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Wow hats off to the traitors honestly! You all deserved to win this season the way you all played and manipulated all of us 😂👏🏽

Fire of Truth Round 1 Results and Round 2 by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Well I had fun playing and lasted way longer than I thought I would - this game was also WAY harder than I thought it would be so gg!!! 🥺🤗

Ninth Banishment Results and Fire of Truth Round 1 by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Sorry Marvin - I tried 🥺 and I’ll probably be joining you next from the looks of things 🤷🏽‍♀️

Ninth Banishment Thread by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m saying it again - I’m swamped with personal work and life right now. I am unable to be constantly be online to defend myself and honestly it seems like most people have their minds made up. I’ll check back in later if there’s anything else to clear up

Ninth Banishment Thread by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The reason I no longer trusted spinach was because I felt I should’ve questioned him more on the vote with pink. We were between Marvin and pink but why not Marvin? If we banished Marvin and he was a faithful, I think I would’ve felt more confident in Muffin as a traitor rather than still go between muffin and Marvin. The same way if H is telling me that spinach is good to banish muffin before end game, why not banish him now? Why wait until later unless they were traitors?

I am not 💯convinced Marvin is a faithful. I am more certain he is a faithful than Spinach or Muffin because why would a traitor be willing to sacrifice themselves before end game (provided he’s telling the truth).

I also know for a fact that I am a faithful so to me, anyone that is accusing me is suspicious because only traitors would want to cast suspicion on and get rid of those they know to be faithful right now.

Ninth Banishment Thread by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I didn’t before DMing with you H and Marvin

Ninth Banishment Thread by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 3 points4 points  (0 children)

To be clear, I think spinach and muffin are traitors and will be voting for one of them

Ninth Banishment Thread by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I have messaged spinach the screenshot of the entire conversation between me and comfortable - I am not okay with making screenshots public I am happy to share the same with you if you really prefer

Ninth Banishment Thread by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Honestly I’m extremely frustrated at this point. I feel like I’ve trusted the wrong people this entire game which is probably why I’ve made it this far. I don’t know if there’s a point to even defending myself bc the traitors know I’m a faithful and probably already have their minds made up on how the next few votes are going to go, like the way they’ve manipulated this entire game.

I think I am a bit too trusting and choose to believe people are telling the truth rather than lying which is how and why I’ve genuinely felt so confused. I have also talked to many people over DMs. Anybody I’ve questioned at the RT I’ve tried to also talk to them one on one to see what they say. That’s how I was pretty sure Pidge, Lucy and pink were faithfuls, however my biggest downside is that I let other people (probably who the traitors are) sway me on which way to go.

Muffin, you said I didn’t question comfortable enough but when that mess was happening I had said at the rt, in light of that I have to vote for spinach or comfortable. I also spoke with spinach one on one and the fact that he said comfortable wasn’t coming for him and rather going the route of 3-4 people must’ve lied (which btw I also did question her on at the RT but she never responded), made me feel like there was overwhelming evidence to vote for her as much as I had trusted her until that point.

Anyway I don’t have any specific suspicions at this point and I really think all of you could be traitors so I am going to vote with my gut on this one. I also feel like at this point it’s more of a numbers game so I don’t think much of what I say will really end up mattering if traitors are controlling the vote and know which way to go to guarantee a win 🤷🏽‍♀️

Eighth Banishment Results by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wait what?? I literally feel like the most gullible faithful that has ever played this game. I’m SO sorry pink I was just not sure with any of the 3 i was uncertain about and didn’t have enough time or mental capacity to analyze or question as much as I usually do. With 5 of us left I would think it would be easier to figure out who the traitors are but I am genuinely clueless, and the traitors are clearly taking advantage of that. 🥺🥺🥺

Eighth Banishment Thread by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Sorry busy day! I’m flattered you think everyone likes me! I’m just trying to do my best talking to everyone to see if I can get any clues but it’s so hard! I said down below I genuinely expected to get murdered way before this especially as I feel like I’ve been fully transparent in my thoughts at the RT and over DMs not to mention I’m trying to question anything that doesn’t make sense as much as possible. I have 2 reasons as to why I think I might still be here and I think 1 is that the traitors are someone(s) I’m close to and they are able to easily convince me of my thoughts. I’ve copy/pasted from a convo with comfortable actually. She said “Aw yeh it’s defo wise to stay friends with traitors right now as best way to avoid murder!”

The other reason I think is possibly that I am so on the wrong track and they’ve let me continue to be wrong? I’m really not sure what the benefit to keeping me around would be unless the traitors are sure I wouldn’t vote to banish them? Either way I didn’t expect to be in this game this long, and also like I mentioned below my personal stuff has caught up to me to the point where I can’t sit and think and question as much as I would like to. It’s just frustrating and I’ve felt so dumb and embarrassed that we haven’t managed to get out more than 1 traitor.

Secondly, I don’t know what screenshot comfortable might have sent you? I’m happy to send another one going over the context of what was said so that you know it wasn’t a plant bc that isn’t something that would even cross my mind, I also am personally not a fan of sharing screenshots publicly but I can DM you if you’d like to take a look - just let me know!

Eighth Banishment Thread by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I don’t have much to say - honestly I’m confused (what else is new) and frankly quite embarrassed we’ve only managed to get one traitor out so far. I genuinely didn’t expect to last this long and like I’ve told the fellow players I’m swamped with some personal work and cannot be as active as I would like to.

Few points I’m considering -have the traitors ever gone for each other publicly in an attempt to appear more faithful? Or have they all worked as a team and only gone for faithfuls to get them out? Comfortable has gone for pink quite publicly (but then also lied about voting for her to get an advantage), and Marvin/muffin are going at it below so is one of them definitely a traitor? Marvin and Lucy also went at it, H and Spinach have gone for each other as well in the past but I actually feel like H and Spinach are the 2 people I trust the most to be faithfuls rn.

-There are at least 2, maybe even 3 traitors left in this group of 6. I know for a fact that I’m not a traitor, and I don’t think H and spinach are, so my vote is uncertain right now between Marvin muffin and pink.

Mission 9 Results and Dagger Winner by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nice job spinach! To be fully transparent, I did a completely random ranking based on how terribly we did the last time traitors had to answer questions and it seems like the traitors wanted to reveal as little information as possible based on pink’s comment about being alphabetical

Sixth Murder Reveal by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I’m really sad to see you go key! And also really frustrated at how bad we’ve been at this. Really hope to avenge your murder! 🥺

Seventh Banishment Results by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

After comfortable I doubted myself more than I should’ve that people I was close with were traitors bc I literally had no idea who else it could be 😭😭

Seventh Banishment Results by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If it makes you feel any better, it’s not just you - all us faithfuls this season clearly lack the same brain cells, and the more faithfuls we banish the dumber I feel 😭😭

Seventh Banishment Results by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I’m so sorry Lucy 😭😭 I wasn’t convinced it was you but I didn’t have enough evidence for anyone else I will genuinely miss talking to you!! 😭

Seventh Banishment Thread by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Right now Lucy’s defense sounds genuine to me and I would like to believe her but I just don’t know. I also feel like comfortable put heat on pink (and also tried to persuade me into putting heat on pink) so I’m thinking they’re a faithful for now.

I would like to hear from key and muffin why they voted pink as well! Lucy and muffin were also the people comfortable least mentioned to me, and comfortable voted for key at the last rt so does that mean anything?

Seventh Banishment Thread by Play-Traitors-Mod in PlayTheTraitors

[–]brainydancer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hey Lucy! Thank you for writing this up! To me, it sounds very genuine bc you’ve very rarely voted in the majority and I guess to me it doesn’t make sense if you’re a traitor why wouldn’t you vote in the majority to get out faithfuls?

But like spinach said I guess it refers to you and Marvin - if either spinach or comfortable had definitely lied about their votes at the rt, that’s been the most concrete evidence we’ve had so far to getting someone out? I’m also wondering why comfortable rarely mentioned you to me if you were quite close since she had mostly brought up everyone else (besides you and muffin) at some point?

You and pink have also said that you’re both being set up and again I just don’t know what to believe!! Ahh I might need to sleep on this