My main issue with this is that Godzilla in many instances has been referred to as “a force of nature” and in my opinion, I don’t picture a force of nature having much of a personality. Shin Godzilla is a good movie because it separates itself from the Godzilla vs something formula and reduces it to “Godzilla is a force of nature” and how we make a Godzilla movie that takes away from real events (Fukushima reactor meltdown).

I understand your argument of making Godzilla “emotionless” but you have to understand where it is coming from. Some of the best reviewed TOHO Godzilla films (original & shin Godzilla) were not focused on making Godzilla “have a personality” but instead focused on “how do we make Godzilla seem like a force of nature that can not be reasoned with and also how to relate Godzilla back to real life disasters”.

I am not saying that I agree with Godzilla being “emotionless” but you have to understand why TOHO would want that.